Developing a Toolbox for Clinical Preliminary Breast Cancer Detection in Different views of Thermogram Images using a Set of Optimal Supervised Classifiers


Department of Bio-Medical Engineering, Institute of Electrical Engineering & Information Technology, Iranian Research Organization for Science and Technology (IROST), Tehran, Iran


A full automatic technique and a user friendly toolbox developed to assist physicians in early clinical detection of breast cancer. Database contains different degrees of thermal images obtained from normal or cancerous mammary tissues of patients with mean age of 42.3 years (SD: ±10.50) which their sympathetic nervous system activated with a cold stimulus on hands. First ROI was determined using full automatic operation and the quality of image improved. Then, some features, including statistical, morphological, frequency domain, histogram and GLCM features were extracted from segmented right and left breast. Subsequently, to achieve the best feature space decreasing complexity and increasing accuracy, feature selectors such as mRMR, SFS, SBS, SFFS, SFBS and GA have been used. Finally to classify and TH labeling, supervised learning techniques such as AdaBoost, SVM, kNN, NB and PNN were applied and compared with each other to find the best suitable one. The experimental results obtained on native database showed the mean accuracy of 88.03% for 0 degree images using combination of mRMR and AdaBoost and for combined 3 degrees using combination of GA and AdaBoost. The maximum accuracy obtained from all degrees and their combinations in before and after ice test is nearly to 100%. 


Main Subjects

1. Liberman, L., Abramson, A.F., Squires, F.B., Glassman,
J.R., Morris, E.A., and Dershaw, D.D. \The
breast imaging reporting and data system: positive
predictive value of mammographic features and -
nal assessment categories", AJR. Am. J. Roentgenol,
171(1), pp. 35-40 (1998).
2. Liberman, L. \Clinical management issues in percutaneous
core breast biopsy", Radiol. Clin. North. Am.,
38(4), pp. 791-807 (2000).
3. Rane, K.P., Joshi, R.R., and Chaudhari, L.A. \IR
Imaging: A new approach for breast cancer detection",
IJARECE (2014). Available from: technicheedu.
4. Zhang, Y.-D., Wang, S.-H., Liu, G., and Yang,
J. \Computer-aided diagnosis of abnormal breasts
in mammogram images by weighted-type fractional
Fourier transform", Advances in Mechanical Engineering,
8(2), pp. 1-11 (2016).
5. Arena, F., Barone, C., and DiCicco, T. \Use of digital
infrared imaging in enhanced breast cancer detection
and monitoring of the clinical response to treatment",
Proceedings of the 25th Annual International Conference
of the IEEE, New York, NY, USA, pp. 1129-1132
6. Gautherie, M., Atlas of Breast Thermography with Speci
c Guidelines for Examination and Interpretation,
PAPUSA, Milan, Italy (1989).
7. Ng, E.Y., Ung, L.N., Ng, F.C., and Sim, L.S.
\Statistical analysis of healthy and malignant breast
A.E. Lashkari and M. Firouzmand/Scientia Iranica, Transactions D: Computer Science & ... 25 (2018) 1545{1560 1559
thermography", J. Med. Eng. Technol., 25(6), pp. 253-
263 (2001).
8. Amalu, W.C., Hobbins, W.B., Head, J.F., and Elliot,
R.L. Infrared Imaging of the Breast-An Overview, The
Biomedical Engineering Handbook, 3rd Ed., Medical
Devices and Systems. CRC Press, Baton Rouge (2006).
9. Ghayoumi Zadeh, H., Haddadnia, J., Hashemian, M.,
and Hassanpour, K. \Diagnosis of breast cancer using
a combination of genetic algorithm and arti cial neural
network in medical infrared thermal imaging", Iran J.
Med. Phys., 9(4), pp. 265-274 (2012).
10. Zhang, H., Li, K.Y., Sun, S.R., Wan, Y.W., Yao,
X.L., and Zhang, X.L. \The Value-exploration of
the clinical breast diagnosis by using thermal tomography",
Fourth International Conference on Natural
Computation, Jinan, China, pp. 138-142 (2008).
11. Williams, K.L., Williams, F.J., and Handley, R.S.
\Infra-red thermometry in the diagnosis of breast
disease", Lancet, 2(7217), pp. 1378-1381 (1961).
12. Parisky, Y.R., Sardi, A., Hamm, R., Hughes, K.,
Esserman, L., and Rust, S. \Ecacy of computerized
infrared imaging analysis to evaluate mammographically
suspicious lesions", AJR. Am. J. Roentgenol,
180(1), pp. 263-269 (2003).
13. Arora, N., Martins, D., Ruggerio, D., Tousimis, E.,
Swistel, A.J., and Osborne, M.P. \E ectiveness of a
noninvasive digital infrared thermal imaging system in
the detection of breast cancer", Am. J. Surg., 196(4),
pp. 523-526 (2008).
14. Kennedy, D.A., Lee, T., and Seely, D. \A comparative
review of thermography as a breast cancer screening
technique", Integr. Cancer. Ther., 8(1), pp. 9-16
15. Tang, X., Ding, H., Yuan, Y., and Wang, Q. \Morphological
measurement of localized temperature increase
amplitudes in breast infrared thermograms and its
clinical application", Biomed Signal Process Control,
3(4), pp. 312-318 (2008).
16. Schaefer, G., Zavisek, M., and Nakashima, T. \Thermography
based breast cancer analysis using statistical
features and fuzzy classi cation", Pattern Recogn.,
42(6), pp. 1133-1137 (2009).
17. Acharya, U.R., Ng, E.Y., Tan, J.H., and Sree, S.V.
\Thermography based breast cancer detection using
texture features and support vector machine", J. Med.
Syst., 36(3), pp. 1503-1510 (2012).
18. Satoto, K.I., Nurhayati, O.D., and Isnanto, R.R.
\Pattern recognition to detect breast cancer thermogram
images based on fuzzy inference system method",
IJCST, 2(3), pp. 484-487 (2011).
19. Kapoor, P., Prasad, S.V.A.V., and Patni, S. \Automatic
analysis of breast tomograms for tumor detection
based on biostatistical feature extraction and
ANN", IJETED, 7(2), pp. 245-255 (2012).
20. Kapoor, P., Prasad, S.V.A.V., and Patni, S. \Image
segmentation and asymmetry analysis of breast thermograms
for tumor detection", IJCA, 50(9), pp. 40-45
21. Nicandro, C.R., Efren, M.M., Yaneli, A.A.M., Enrique,
M.D.C.M., Gabriel, A.M.H., and Nancy, P.C. \Evaluation
of the diagnostic power of thermography in breast
cancer using Bayesian network classi ers", Comput.
Math. Methods Med., Article ID 264246, p. 10 (2013).
22. Dinsha, D. and Manikandaprabu, N. \Breast tumor
segmentation and classi cation using SVM and
Bayesian from thermogram images", Unique J. Eng.
Adv. Sci., 2(2), pp. 147-151 (2014).
23. Fanavaran Madoon Ghermez (FMG) Co., Ltd [Internet].
Available from: (Accessed
Date: April 2016).
24. Imam Khomeini Hospital Ocial Website [Internet].
Available from: (Accessed
Date: April 2016).
25. Lashkari, A.E., Pak, F., and Firouzmand, M. \Full intelligent
cancer classi cation of thermal breast images
to assist physician in clinical diagnostic applications",
J. Med. Signals Sens., 6(1), pp. 12-24 (2016).
26. Expanding the use of thermal imaging in the diagnosis
of breast cancer. Documents 002-005, Ver 01. Available
from: (Accessed Date: April 2016).
27. Gautherie, M., Haehnel, P., Walter, J.P., and Keith,
L.G. \Thermovascular changes associated with in situ
and minimal breast cancers. Results of an ongoing
prospective study after four years", J. Reprod. Med.,
32(11), pp. 833-842 (1987).
28. Peng, H., Long, F. and Ding, C. \Feature selection
based on mutual information: criteria of maxdependency,
max-relevance, and min-redundancy",
IEEE Trans Pattern Anal Mach Intell, 27(8), pp.
1226-1238 (2005).
29. Whitney, A.W. \A direct method of nonparametric
measurement selection", IEEE Transaction on Computers,
20(9), pp. 1100-1103 (1971).
30. Pudil, P., Novovicova, J., and Kittler, J. \Floating
search methods in feature-selection", Pattern Recogn.
Lett., 15(11), pp. 1119-1125 (1994).
31. Martin-Bautista, M.J. and Vila, M.A. \A survey of
genetic feature selection in mining issues", 2, pp. 1314-
1321 (1999).
32. Freund, Y. and Schapire, R.E. \A decision-theoretic
generalization of on-line learning and an application to
boosting", Journal of Computer and System Sciences,
55(1), pp. 119-139 (1997).
33. Schapire, R.E. and Singer, Y. \Improved boosting
algorithms using con dence-rated predictions", Mach.
Learn., 37(3), pp. 297-336 (1999).
34. Burges, C.J.C. \A tutorial on support vector machines
for pattern recognition", Data Mining Knowl. Discov.,
2, pp. 121-167 (1998).
35. Mitchell, T.M., Machine Learning, Burr Ridge, IL:
McGraw Hill (1997).
36. Specht, D.F. \Probabilistic neural network for classi-
cation, map, or associative memory", In Proc. IEEE
Int Conf Neural Netw, 1, pp. 525-532 (1988).
1560 A.E. Lashkari and M. Firouzmand/Scientia Iranica, Transactions D: Computer Science & ... 25 (2018) 1545{1560
37. Lee, M.Y. and Yang, C.S. \Entropy-based feature
extraction and decision tree induction for breast cancer
diagnosis with standardized thermograph images",
Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine,
100(3), pp. 169-282 (2010).
38. Yaneli, A.A.M., Nicandro, C.R., Efren, M.M., Enrique,
M.D.C.M., Nancy, P.C. and Gabriel, A.M.H.
\Assessment of Bayesian network classi ers as tools
for discriminating breast cancer pre-diagnosis based on
three diagnostic methods", Lecture Notes in Computer
Science, 7629, pp. 419-431 (2012).
39. Araujo, M.C., Lima, R.C.F., and de Souza, R.M.C.R.
\Interval symbolic feature extraction for thermography
breast cancer detection", Expert Syst. Appl., 14(15),
pp. 6728-6737 (2014).