A virtual blind spot identification system for construction projects

Document Type : Article


Department of Civil Engineering, Anadolu University, Iki Eylul Campus, 26555 Eskisehir, Turkey


The construction industry is recognized as one of the most hazardous industries. Visibility-related accidents are the cause of a significant portion of the total fatalities within the construction industry. Limited visibility due to construction equipment blind spots and a lack of visibility in construction areas such as slab openings are among the main causes of these fatalities. This study introduces the Virtual Blind Spot Identification System (VIBSIM), which was designed to identify and examine blind spots in construction equipment and construction sites. The VIBSIM consists of a three-dimensional point cloud model that uses 3ds Max software in conjunction with a V-Ray rendering motor. A real case is used to validate the applicability of the proposed system. The results indicate that the system can significantly improve safety applications for construction projects. Moreover, the system can aid construction managers in making decisions regarding the better management of such safety applications for construction projects.


Main Subjects

1.Wua,  W.,  Gibb,  A.G.F.  and  Li,  Q.  Accident  pre-cursors  and  near  misses  on  construction  sites:    aninvestigative tool to derive information from accidentdatabases",Saf. Sci.,48(7), pp. 845-858 (2010).2.Bureau  of  Labor  Statistics,Census  of  Fatal  Occupa-tional  Injuries  (CFOI)  -  Current  and  Revised  Data(2014).3.Mohamed, S. Empirical investigation of constructionsafety management activities and performance in Aus-tralia",Saf. Sci.,33(3), pp. 129-142 (1999).4.Marks,   E.D.   and   Teizer,   J.   Method   for   testingproximity   detection   and   alert   technology   for   safe
116S. Kivrak and F. Rostami Kia/Scientia Iranica, Transactions A: Civil Engineering 25 (2018) 109{117construction  equipment  operation",Constr.  Manag.Econ.,31(6), pp. 636-646 (2013).5.Zhang,  S.,  Teizer,  J.,  Lee,  J.K.,  Eastman,  C.M.  andVenugopal, M. Building information modeling (BIM)and safety:  automatic safety checking of constructionmodels and schedules",Automat. Constr.,29, pp. 183-195 (2013).6.OSHA,OSHA  Seeks  Comments  on  How  to  PreventWorker Injuries and Deaths from Reinforcing ConcreteActivities and Vehicle Backovers, Occupational Safety& Health Administration (2012).7.Fosbroke,  D.E.  NIOSH  reports!    Studies  on  heavyequipment  blind  spots  and  internal  trac  control",Roadway   Work   Zone   Safety&Health   Conference,Baltimore, Maryland (2004).8.Akula, M., Lipman, R.R., Franaszek, M., Saidi, K.S.,Cheok, G.S. and Kamat, V.R. Real-time drill moni-toring and control using building information modelsaugmented with 3D imaging data",Automat. Constr.,36, pp. 1-15 (2013).9.Ray, S.J. and Teizer, J. Computing 3D blind spots ofconstruction equipment:  Implementation and evalua-tion of an automated measurement and visualizationmethod  utilizing  range  point  cloud  data",Automat.Constr.,36, pp. 95-107 (2013).10.Teizer, J., Allread, B.S. and Mantripragada, U. Au-tomating the blind spot measurement of constructionequipment",Automat. Constr.,19, pp. 491-501 (2010).11.Hinze, J.W. and Teizer, J. Visibility-related fatalitiesrelated  to  construction  equipment",Saf.  Sci.,49(5),pp. 709-718 (2011).12.Zhou,  Z.,  Irizarry,  J. and Li,  Q. Applying advancedtechnology   to   improve   safety   management   in   theconstruction  industry:   a  literature  review",Constr.Manag. Econ.,31(6), pp. 606-622 (2013).13.Teizer, J., Cheng, T. and Fang, Y. Location trackingand data visualization technology to advance construc-tion ironworkers' education and training in safety andproductivity",Automat. Constr.,35, pp. 53-68 (2013).14.Pradhananga,  N.  and  Teizer,  J.  Automatic  spatio-temporal  analysis  of  construction  site  equipment  op-erations using GPS data",Automat.  Constr.,29, pp.107-122 (2013).15.Yang,  L.R.  Impacts  of  automation  technology  onquality  of  project  deliverables  in  the  Taiwanese  con-struction industry",Can. J. Civil Eng.,36(3), pp. 402-414 (2009).16.Ko,  C.H.  Integrating  RFID,  web-based  technology,and arti cial intelligence in engineering management",Scientia  Iranica  -  Transactions  A:  Civil  Engineering,22(2), pp. 299-312 (2015).17.Gai,  M.,  Cho,  Y.K. and Xu,  Q. Real-time 3D visu-alization of heavy construction equipment operationsusing  LADAR",Proceedings  of  Computing  in  CivilEngineering, pp. 889-896 (2013).18.Choe,   S.,   Leite,   F.,   Seedah,   D.  and  Caldas,   C.Evaluation  of  sensing  technology  for  the  preventionof  backover  accidents  in  construction  work  zones",ITcon.,19, pp. 1-19 (2014).19.Cho,   Y.K.   and   Gai,   M.   Projection-recognition-projection  method  for  automatic  object  recognitionand  registration  for  dynamic  heavy  equipment  oper-ations",Journal  of  Computing  in  Civil  Engineering,28,Special  Issue:   2012  International  Conference  onComputing in Civil Engineering, A4014002 (2014).20.Wang, C. and Chob, Y.K. Smart scanning and nearreal-time 3D surface modeling of dynamic constructionequipment from a point cloud",Automat. Constr.,49,pp. 239-249 (2015).21.Ru , T.M. Monitoring blind spots - a major concernfor  haul  trucks",Eng.  Min.  J.,202(12),  pp.  17-26(2001).22.Hefner,  R.E.,Construction  Vehicle  and  EquipmentBlind Area Diagrams,   National Institute for Occupa-tional Safety and Health (2004).23.NIOSH,Highway  Work  Zone  Safety,  Center  for  Dis-ease Control and Prevention (2011).24.Teizer, J. 3D range imaging camera sensing for activesafety in construction",ITcon.,13, pp. 103-117 (2008).25.Teizer, J., Allread, B.S., Fullerton, C.E. and Hinze, J.Autonomous pro-active real-time construction workerand  equipment  operator  proximity  safety  alert  sys-tem",Automat. Constr.,19, pp. 630-640 (2010).26.Marks, E.D., Cheng, T. and Teizer, J. Laser scanningfor  safe  equipment  design  that  increases  operatorvisibility by measuring blind spots",ASCE J. Constr.Eng. Manag.,139(8), pp. 1006-1014 (2013).27.Bostelman, R., Teizer, J., Ray, S.J., Agronin, M. andAlbanese,  D.  Methods  for  improving  visibility  mea-surement  standards  of  powered  industrial  vehicles",Saf. Sci.,62, pp. 257-270 (2014).28.Li,   H.,   Chan,   G.  and  Skitmore,   M.  Integratingreal time positioning systems to improve blind liftingand loading crane operations",Constr. Manag. Econ.,31(6), pp. 596-605 (2013).29.Wua, H., Tao, J., Li, X., Chi, X., Li, H., Hua, X., Yang,R., Wange, S. and Chen, N. A location based serviceapproach for collision warning systems in concrete damconstruction",Saf. Sci.,51(1), pp. 338-346 (2013).
S. Kivrak and F. Rostami Kia/Scientia Iranica, Transactions A: Civil Engineering 25 (2018) 109{11711730.Shapira,  A.,  Simcha,  M.  and  Goldenberg,  M.  Inte-grative model for quantitative evaluation of safety onconstruction sites with tower cranes",ASCE  Constr.Eng. Manag.,138(11), pp. 1281-1293 (2012).31.Shapira, A., Filin, S. and Wicnudel, A. Quantitativeanalysis  of  blind  tower-crane  lifts  using  laserscan-ning information",Constr. Innov.,14(3), pp. 383-403(2014).32.Lee, G., Cho, J., Ham, S., Lee, T., Lee, G., Yun, S.H.and Yang, H.J. A BIM- and sensor-based tower cranenavigation  system  for  blind  lifts",Automat.  Constr.,26, pp. 1-10 (2012).33.Lee,   U.K.,   Kang,   K.I.,   Kim,   G.H.  and  Cho,   H.Improving  tower  crane  productivity  using  wirelesstechnology",Comput-Aided  Civ.  Inf.,21(8), pp. 594-604 (2006).34.Shapira,  A.,  Rosenfeld,  Y.  and  Mizrahi,  I.  Visionsystem  for  tower  cranes",ASCE   J.   Constr.   Eng.Manag.,134(5), pp. 320-332 (2008).35.Fang,  Y.  and  Teizer,  J.  A  multi-user  virtual  3Dtraining environment to advance collaboration amongcrane  operator  and  ground  personnel  in  blind  lifts",Proceedings  of  the  Computing  in  Civil  and  BuildingEngineering, ASCE, pp. 2071-2078 (2014).36.Cheng, T. and Teizer, J. Real-time resource locationdata  collection  and  visualization  technology  for  con-struction safety and activity monitoring applications",Automat. Constr.,34, pp. 3-15 (2013).37.Cheng,   T.  and  Teizer,   J.  Modeling  tower  craneoperator  visibility  to  minimize  the  risk  of  limitedsituational awareness",ASCE  J.  Comput.  Civil  Eng.,28(3), 04014004 (2014).38.Kajiya,J.T.Therenderingequation",SIGGRAPH   '86   Proceedings   of   the   13th   AnnualConference   on   Computer   Graphics   and   InteractiveTechniques,20(4), pp. 143-150 (1986).39.Laub, S.,VRAY for C4D1.0 Manual & Starter Guide(2007).40.ISO   Earth-moving   machinery-Operator's    eld   ofview-Test method and performance criteria",Interna-tional Standard, Part 2:  Evaluation Method(2011).41.Maunder, M.J. de F. and Moore, P.,Lights in the Sky:Identifying  and  Understanding  Astronomical  and  Me-teorological  Phenomena, Springer Publishing, London(2007).42.Barber,  E.L.  Strength  and  range-of-motion  exami-nation  skills  for  the  clinical  orthoptist",J.  Prosthet.Orthot.,5, pp. 49-51 (1993)