Comparison of hydrodynamic performance of a monohull planing vessel equipped by combined transverse step and transom wedge with a no appendage model: An experimental study

Document Type : Article

Authors

Department of Marine Technology, Amirkabir University of Technology, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

One of the most well-known strategies to eliminate or reduce the longitudinal instabilities in planing hull, is to reduce the trim of the craft. In the current study, porpoising is controlled through creating a transverse step, and the combination of adding a wedge to the stern and transverse step in the vessel. Usually, performance of stepped boats is not suitable in pre-planing regime. However, through the proposed method, stepped model performance can be improved prior to the planing regime. The investigated craft is a 2.56 m long monohull high speed model with speed range of 1,3,5,7 and 9 m/s. The obtained results indicate that best performance is acquired by the step and wedge model at the beginning of the planing regime. From 3 to 7 m/s, drag of stepped and wedged models has the lowest value and above 7 m/s and at 9 m/s, the stepped model has the lowest resistance. Among the investigated methods, using combined step and wedge indicates largest reduction in trim angle (At speeds of 3 to 9 m/s). It can therefore be concluded that model equipped by combination of wedge and step improves the poor performance of the stepped models prior to the planing regime.

Keywords

References

References
[1] Martin, M. “Theoretical Predictions of Motions of High-Speed Planing Boats in Waves”, David W. Taylor Naval Ship Research and Development Center, (1976).
[2] Zarnick, E. “A Nonlinear Mathematical Model of Motions of a Planing Boat in Regular Waves”, David W. Taylor Naval Ship Research and Development Center, (1978).
[3] Zarnick, E. “A Nonlinear Mathematical Model of Motions of a Planing Boat in Irregular Waves”, David W. Taylor Naval Ship Research and Development Center, (1979).
[4] Ghadimi, P. Dashtimanesh, A. Faghfoore Maghrebi, Y. “initiating a mathematical model for prediction of 6 DOF motion of planing crafts inregular waves”, International Journal of Eng. Math. 2003, pp. 1–15 (2013).
[5] Ghadimi, P. Tavakoli, T. Dashtimanesh, A. “An analytical procedure for time domain simulation of roll motion of the warped planing hulls”, International Journal of Mech. Eng.Part M: J. Eng. Marit. Environ. (2015).
[6] Ghadimi, P. Tavakoli, S. Dashtimanesh, A. “Coupled heave and pitch motions of planing hulls at non-zero heel angle”,Applied Ocean Research, 59, pp. 286–303 (2016).
[7] Clement, EP. and Pope, JD. “Stepless and stepped planing hulls graphs for performance prediction and design. Bethesda (MD)” David W. Taylor Naval Ship Research and Development Center, (1961). 
[8] Clement, ­ EP. and Koelbel, JO. “Effects of step design on the performance of planning motorboats”, Paper presented at: 4th Biennial Power Boat Symposium. The Society of Naval Architects and Marine Engineers; Miami (FL), USA, (1991).
[9] Clement, EP. “A configuration for a stepped planing boat having minimum drag. Bethesda (MD)”, David W. Taylor Naval Ship Research and Development Center, (2003).
[10] Barry, C.D. and Duffty, V. “The Stepped Hull Hybrid Hydrofoil”, Fifth International Conference on Fast Sea Transportation, (1999).
[11] Savitsky, D. Morabito, R. “Surface wave contours associated with the forebody wake of stepped planing hulls”, International Journal of Marine Technology, 47(1), pp. 1–16 (2009).
[12] Svahn, D. Performance prediction of hulls with transverse steps [thesis]. Stockholm: Marina System Centre for Naval Architecture, KTH University, (2010).
[13] Garland, W.R. and Maki, K.J. “A Numerical Study of a Two-Dimensional Stepped Planing Surface”, Journal of Ship Production and Design, 28, pp. 212-239 (2012).
[14] Taunton, D.J. Hudson, D.A. Shenoi, R.A. “Characteristics of a series of high-speed hard chine planing hulls” part 2: performance in waves. International Journal of Small Craft Technol. 153, pp. 1–22 (2011).
[15] O’Reilly, C. Murphy, M. Piro, D. et al. "Modeling the Flow over Planing Hulls with Ventilated or Cavitating Steps”, (2014).
[16] Loni, A. Ghadimi, P. Nowruzi, H. et al. "Developing a computer program for mathematical investigation of stepped planning hull characteristics", International Journal of Physical Research (2013).
[17] Lee, E. Pavkov, M. Mccue-Weil, W. “The systematic variation of step configuration and displacement for a double-step planing craft”, Journal of Ship Prod Des. 30, pp. 89–97 (2014).
[18] Veysi, S.T.G. Bakhtiari, M. Ghassemi, H. et al. "Toward numerical modeling of the stepped and non-stepped planing hull", Journal of the Brazilian Society of Mechanical Sciences and Engineering, 37(6), pp. 1635-1645 (2015).
[19] De Marco, A. Mancini, S. Miranda, S. et al. "Experimental and numerical hydrodynamic analysis of a stepped planing hull", Applied Ocean Research, 64, pp. 135–154 (2017).
[20] Najafi, A. Nowruzi, H. Salari, M. et al. “The hydrodynamic resistance of stepped planing hulls under different geometrical and physical conditions” Journals of the Maritime University of Szczecin. 58 (130), pp. 24–31 (2019).
[21] Najafi, A. and Nowruzi, H. “On hydrodynamic analysis of stepped planing crafts”, Journal of Ocean Engineering and Science. 4, pp. 238–251 (2019).
[22] Chooran, T. Shafaghat, R. Yoosefi, R. “Numerical Investigation of Step Depth Effects on Hydrodynamic Performance of Planing Hull Using Dynamic Mesh and Two Degree of Freedom Model”. AUT Journal of Mechanical Engineering. 3(2), pp. 139-148 (2019).
[23] Kazemi, H. Salari, M. Nowruzi, H. et al. “Hydrodynamics analysis of stepped planing hull under different physical and geometrical conditions”, Journal of the Brazilian Society of Mechanical Sciences and Engineering. 41, pp. 360-372 (2019).
[24] Ghadimi, P. Panahi, S. Tavakoli, S. “Hydrodynamic study of a double‑stepped planing craft through numerical simulations”, Journal of the Brazilian Society of Mechanical Sciences and Engineering.41:2 (2019).
[25] Dashtimanesh, A. Roshan, F. Tavakoli, S. et al. “Effects of configuration on hydrodynamic performance of one and doubled-stepped planing flat plates: A numerical simulation” Journal of engineering and maritime environment. 234(1), pp. 181-195 (2019). 
[26] Doustdar, M. and Kazemi, H. “Effects of fixed and dynamic mesh methods on simulation of stepped planing craft”, Journal of Ocean Engineering and Science. 4, pp. 33–48 (2019).
[27] Yang, D. Sun, Z. Jiang, Y. et al. “A Study on the Air Cavity under a Stepped Planing Hull”, Journal of Marine Science and Engineering. doi:10.3390/jmse7120468. (2019).
[28] Cucinotta, F. Guglielmino, E. Sfravara, F. “A critical CAE analysis of the bottom shape of a multi stepped air cavity planing hull” Applied Ocean Research 82, pp. 130–142, (2019).
[29] Ghadimi, P. and Panahi, S. “Numerical investigation of hydrodynamic forces acting on the non-stepped and double-stepped planing hulls during yawed steady motion”, Journal of engineering and maritime environment, DOI: 10.1177/1475090217751549. (2019).
[30] Nourghassemi, H. Ghassemi, H. Taghva, H. “Numerical Hydrodynamic Results of the Two Stepped Planing Hull”, American Journal of Mechanical Engineering. 6(3), pp. 93-97, (2018).
[31] Esfandiari, A. Tavakoli, S. Dashtimanesh, A. “Comparison between the Dynamic Behavior of the Non-stepped and Double-stepped Planing Hulls in Rough Water: A Numerical Study”, Journal of Ship Production and Design, (2019).
[32] Najafi, A. Nowruzi, H. Karami, M. et al. “Experimental investigation of the wetted surfaces of stepped planing hulls”, doi.org/10.1016/j.oceaneng.2019.106164. (2019).
[33] Judgea, C. Mousaviraad, M. Sternc, F. et al. “Experiments and CFD of a high-speed Deep-V planing hull––Part I: Calm water”, doi.org/10.1016/j.apor.2020.102060. (2020).
[34] Niazmand, B.R. Vitiellob, L. Mancini, S. et al. “Calm-water performance of a boat with two swept steps at high-speeds: Laboratory measurements and mathematical modeling” International Conference on Industry 4.0 and Smart Manufacturing (ISM 2019). pp. 467–474 (2020).
[35] Afriantoni, A. Romadhoni, R. Santoso, B. “Study on the Stability of High Speed Craft with Step Hull Angle Variations”, The 8th International and National Seminar on Fisheries and Marine Science (2020).
[36] Savitsky, D. and Brown, P.W.” Procedures for hydrodynamic evaluation of planning hulls in smooth and rough water”, Marine technology, 13(4), pp. 381-400 (1976).
[37] Grigoropoulos, G. and Loukakis, T. “Effect of wedges on the calm water resistance of planing hulls”, In Intl. Conf. of Mar. Ind. Dev. MARIND, volume 96, (1996).
[38] Katayama, T. “Mechanism of porpoising instabilities for high-speed planing craft”, In: Proceedings of the Sixth, ISOPE Pacific/Asia Offshore Mechanics Symposium, (2004).
[39] Ikeda, Y. and Katayama, T. “Porpoising oscillations of very-high-speed marine craft”, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences, 358(1771), pp. 1905– 1915 (2000).
[40] Morabito, M.G. “Investigation of dynamic instabilities in high-speed, shallow-draft boats”, Transactions - Society of Naval Architects and Marine Engineers, 124, pp. 296–311 (2016).
[41] Millard, A. “Effect of wedges on the performance characteristics of two planing hulls”, Journal of Ship Research, 20(4), pp. 224-232 (1987).
[42] Steen, S. Alterskjar, S.A. Velgaard, A. et al. “Performance of a planing craft with mid-mounted interceptor”, In: 10th International Conference on Fast Sea Transportation, Athens, Greece, (2009).
[43] Mansoori, M. and Fernandes, A.C. “Hydrodynamic design of the interceptor on a 2D flat plate by CFD and experiments. Journal of Hydronautics”, DOI: http:// dx. doi. org/ 10. 1016/S1001-6058(15)60558-8. (2015).
[44] Mansoori, M. and Fernandes, A.C. “The interceptor hydrodynamic analysis for controlling the porpoising instability in high speed crafts”. Applied Ocean Research; 57, pp. 40-51 (2016).
[45]Tsai, J.F. Hwang, J.L. Chau, S.W. et al. “Study of Hydrofoil Assistance Arrangement for Catamaran with Stern Flap and Interceptor”, In: Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on FAST Sea Transportation, Southampton, UK, Sep., (2001).
[46] Tsai, F. Hwang, J.L. “Study on the compound effects of interceptor with stern flap for two fast mono hulls”, In: Proceedings of the International Conference on OCEANS '04. MTTS/IEEE TECHNO-OCEAN '04, (2005).
[47] Karimi, M.H. Seif, M.S. Abbaspoor, M. “An experimental study of interceptor’s effectiveness on hydrodynamic performance of high-speed planing crafts”, Polish Maritime Research.  20, pp. 21-29 (2013).
[48] Ghadimi, P. Loni, A. Nowruzi, H. et al.” Paramteric study of the effects of trim tabs on running trim and resistance of planing hulls”, Advances in shipping and Ocean Engineering, 3(1), pp. 1-12 (2014).
[49] Pourdel, H. Hassanzadeh Afrouzi, H. Akbari, O.A. et al. “Numerical investigation of turbulent flow and heat transfer in flat tube”, Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry,  135, pp. 3471–3483 (2019).
[50] Akbari, O.A. Toghraie, D. Karimipour, A. “Numerical simulation of heat transfer and turbulent flow of water nanofluids copper oxide in rectangular microchannel with semi-attached rib”, Advances in Mechanical Engineering 8(4), pp. 1–25 (2016).
[51] Hassanzadeh, H. Ahmadian, M. Toghraie, D. “Statistical analysis of pulsating non-Newtonian flow in a corrugated channel using Lattice-Boltzmann method” Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications 29 (3), pp. 915-934 (2019).
[52] Ghadimi, P. Sajedi, S.M. Tavakoli, S. “Experimental study of the wedge effects on the performance of a hard-chine planing craft in calm water”, International journal science & technology, 26(3), pp. 1316-1334 (2019).
[53] Karafiath, G. and Fisher, S. “The effect of stern wedges on ship powering performance”, Naval Engineers Journal, 99(3), pp. 27–38 (1987).
[54] Wang, C.T. “Wedge effect on planing hulls”, Journal of Hydronautics, 14(4), pp. 122-124 (1980).
[55] Jang, S.H. Lee, H.J. Joo, Y.R. et al. “Some practical design aspects of appendages for passenger vessels”, International journal of Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering, 1, pp. 50-56 (2009).
[56] Ghadimi, P. Loni, A. Nowruzi, H. et al. “Parametric study of the effects of trim tabs on running trim and resistance of planing hulls”. Advances in shipping and Ocean Engineering, 3(1), pp. 1-12 (2014).
[57] Savitsky, D. “Hydrodynamic Design of Planing Hulls”, Marine Technology, 1(1), pp. 71-95 (1964).
[58] Ikeda, Y. Yokmi, K. Hamaski, J. et al. “Simulation of running attitudes and resistance of a high-speed craft using a database of hydrodynamic forces obtained by fully captive model experiments”. In: 2nd International Conference on Fast Sea Transportation, Athens, Greece, (1993).
[59] Ghadimi, P. Tavakoli, S. Feizi Chakab, M.A. et al. “Introducing a particular mathematical model for predicting the resistance and performance of prismatic planing hulls in calm water by means of total pressure distribution”, Journal of Naval Architecture and Marine Engineering, 12(2), pp. 73-94 (2015).
[60] Martin, M. “Theoretical determination of porpoising instability of high-speed planing boat”, David Taylor Naval Ship Research and Development Center, Report No. 76-0068, (1976).
[61] Xu, L. and Troesch, A.W. “A study on hydrodynamic of asymmetric planing surfaces”, In: Proceedings of the 5thInternational Conference on Fast Sea Transportation (FAST 99), Seattle, Washington, USA, (1999).   
[62] Ghadimi, P. Tavakoli, S. Dashtimanesh, A. et al. “Steady performance prediction of a heeled planing boat in calm water using asymmetric 2D+T model”, Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part M: Journal of Engineering for the Maritime Environment, (2016a),  
[63] Ghadimi, P. Tavakoli, S. Dashtimanesh, A. et al. “developing a computer program for detailed study of planing hull’s spray based on Morabito’s approach”. Journal of Marine Science and Application.13 (4), pp. 402-415 (2014).
[64] Mancini, S. Pensa, C. Vittelo, L. et al. “The Failed Project of the “Heavy” MAS”, Nautical and Maritime Culture, from the Past to the Future International, Conference on Nautical and Maritime Culture, pp. 159-169 (2019).
[65] Jokar, H. Zeinali, H. Tamaddondard, H. “Planing craft control using pneumatically driven trim tab”, Journal of Mathematics and Computers in Simulation. (2020).
 
[66] Song, K. Guo, C. Wang, C. et al. “Numerical analysis of the effects of stern flaps on ship resistance and propulsion performance”, doi.org/10.1016/j.oceaneng.2019.106621. (2019).
 
[67] Wang, X. Liu, L. Zhang, Z. et al. “Numerical study of the stern flap effect on catamaran’ seakeeping characteristic in regular head waves”, doi.org/10.1016/j.oceaneng.2020.107172. (2020).
 
[68] Hou, H. Krajewski, M. Ilter, K. et al. “An experimental investigation of the impact of retrofitting an underwater stern foil on the resistance and motion”, doi.org/10.1016/j.oceaneng.2020.107290. (2020).
 
[69] Deng, R. Chen, S. Wu, T. et al. “Investigation on the influence induced by interceptor on the viscous flow field of deep-Vee vessel”, doi.org/10.1016/j.oceaneng.2019.106735. (2020).
 
[70] Zou, J. Lu, S. Jiang, Y. et al. “Experimental and Numerical Research on the Influence of Stern Flap Mounting Angle on Double-Stepped Planing Hull Hydrodynamic Performance”, Journal of Marine Science and Engineering (2019).
 
[71] Ghadimi, P. Sajedi, S.M. Tavakoli, S. “Experimental study of the wedge effects on the performance of a hard-chine planing craft in calm water”. International journal science & technology 26(3), pp. 1316-1334 (2019).
[72] Karimi, M. Seif, M. Abbaspoor, M.  “An experimental study of interceptor’s effectiveness on hydrodynamic performance of high-speed planing crafts”, Polish Maritime Research, 20. pp. 21-29 (2013).
[73] Gassman, W., Kartinen, S. An Investigation into the Effects of the Step Location and the Longitudinal Center of Gravity Location on the Performance of Stepped Planing Hulls. Webb institute, Glen Cove, NY (1994).
[74] Becker, C., Loreto, A., Shell, J. A Systematic Study of Stepped Planing Hulls, Glen Cove, NY: Webb Institute (2008).
[75] Taunton, D.J. Hudson, D.A. Shenoi, R.A. “Characteristics of a series of high speed hard chine planing hills- Part 1: Performance in calm water”, International Journal of Small Craft Technology; 152 (2), pp. 55-74 (2010).
[76] Suwasono, B. Akbar, H.M.A. Sahir, A. et al. “Outrigger RC Boat Model Hull Development as A High SpeedCraft Based On Resistance and Lift Force”, Procedia Engineering    194, pp. 197 – 202 (2017).
[77] Cucinotta, F. Guglielmino, E. Sfravara, F. “An experimental comparison between different artificial air cavity designs for a planing hull (PART I)”, Ocean Engineering 140, pp. 233-243 (2017).
[78] Kim, D.J. Kim, S.Y. You, Y.J. et al. “Design of high-speed planing hulls for the improvement of resistance and seakeeping performance”. International Journal of Naval Architecture, 5, pp. 161-177 (2013).
[79] Ma, W.J. Sun, H.B. Zou, J. et al. “Test studies of the resistance and seakeeping performance of trimaran planing hull”, Polish Maritime Research, 22, pp. 22-27 (2015).
[80] Jiang, Y. Zou, J. Hu, A. et al. “Analysis of tunnel hydrodynamic characteristics for planing trimaran by model test and numerical simulations”, Ocean Engineering, 113, pp. 101-110 (2016).
[81] Seo, J. Choi, H.K. Jeong, U.C. et al. “Model tests on resistance and seakeeping performance of wave-piercing high-speed vessel with spray rails”, International Journal of Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering 8(5), pp. 442-455 (2016).
[82] ITTC—Recommended Procedures and Guidelines, 24th ITTC 7.5-02 07-02.1, 2013.
Scientia Iranica
Volume 28, Issue 4
Transactions on Mechanical Engineering (B)
July and August 2021
Pages 2187-2201

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 05 July 2020
  • Revise Date: 14 August 2020
  • Accept Date: 09 November 2020

Share

How to cite

Statistics