Assessment of optimum slurry pipe design for minimum erosion

Document Type : Article


1 Mechanical and Industrial Engineering Department, Indian Institute of Technology, Roorkee, 247667, India

2 Mechanical Engineering Department, Thapar University, Patiala, 147001, India


Particulate erosion is a major concern in slurry handling unit of a thermal power plant. The pipe bends are the most erosion affected element of a pipeline unit thus, a cost-effective method to reduce pipeline erosion is highly desirable. This work aims to suggest the optimal pipe bend design to minimize the particulate erosion by analyzing the erosion wear in geometrically different pipe bends for bottom ash slurry flow by using Computational Fluid Dynamics code FLUENT. A Three-dimensional simulation study of erosion wear is carried out by implementing Euler-Lagrange modeling along with the standard k-ε turbulence model to solve the complex multi-phase flow. Pipe bends of different bending angle (30°, 45°, 60°, and 90°), diameter (50 to 250 mm) and bending ratio (r/D = 1 to 2.5) are evaluated at different flow condition. The wear location gets shifted to the upper section of the bend and its magnitude is significantly reduced with the increase in pipe diameter and bending angle. The dynamics of multiphase slurry through different bends is analyzed to understand the complex wear phenomenon. The simulation result shows good agreement with the published findings. Finally, a least erosion affected pipe bend profile is suggested for slurry transport unit.


1.    Modi, O.P., Dasgupta, R., Prasad, B.K., Jha, A.K., Yegneswaran, A.H. and Dixit, G.  "Erosion of a High-Carbon Steel in Coal and Bottom-Ash Slurries", J. Mater. and Eng Perform., 9, 522–529 (2000).
2.   Shah, S.R., Rastogi, S. and Mathis, O. "Application of Dry Bottom Ash Removal and Transportation for Utilization", Fly Ash India, (2005). 
3.  Behera, S., Sahu, A.K., Das, S., Senapati, P.K., and Mishra, S.K. "Scale-Up Design and Erosion Studies of Bottom Ash in Pneumatic Conveying System", Coal Combustion and Gasification Products, 5, 1–8 (2013).
4.   Brown G.J "Erosion Prediction in Slurry pipeline tee-junctions". Appl. Math. Model., 26,155–170 (2002).     
5.    Zhu, M., Sun, L., Ou, G., Wang, K., Wang, K., Sun, Y.   "Erosion corrosion failure analysis of the elbow in sour water stripper overhead condensing reflux system", Eng. Fail. Anal.,  62, 93–102 (2012).
6.    Njobuenwu, D.O. and  Fairweather M. "Modelling of pipe bend erosion by dilute particle suspensions" Comput. Chem. Eng., 4, 235–247 (2012).
7.    Badr, H.M. and  Habib, M.A. "Effect of Flow Velocity and Particle Size on Erosion in a Pipe with Sudden Contraction", The 6th Saudi Engineering Conference, KFUPM, Dhahran, December.  5, 79-95 (2002).
8.    Wee, S.K. and Yap, Y.J. " CFD study of sand erosion in pipeline",  J. Petrol. Sci. Eng., 176, 269–278 (2019). 
9.    Kannojiya, V., Kumar, S., Kanwar, M. and Mohapatra, S.K. "Simulation of Erosion Wear in Slurry Pipe Line Using CFD", Appl. Mech. Mate., 852, 459–465 (2016). 
10.     Kannojiya, V., Deshwal, M. and Deshwal, D. "Numerical analysis of solid particle erosion in pipe elbow." Mater. Today. Proc., 5, 5021-5030 (2018).
11.    Bernardo, S., Mori, M., Peres, A.P. and isio Dion,  R.P. "3-D computational fluid dynamics for gas and gas-particle flows in a cyclone with different inlet section angles", Powder Technol., 162, 190–200, (2006).
12.     Borkowski, P. and Sienicki, A. "Contacts Erosion Modelling Using Ansys Computer Software And Experimental Research", Arch. Metall. Mater., 60(2),551-560, (2015).
13.    Zhang, P., Roberts, R.M. and Benard, A. "Computational guidelines and an empirical model for particle deposition in curved pipes using an Eulerian-Lagrangian approach", J. Aerosol Sci., 53, 1-20 (2012).
14.     Zahedi P., Karimi, S., Mahdavi, M. et al. "Parametric analysis of erosion in 90 degree and long radius bends", ASME Proceeding, Fluids Engineering Division Summer Meeting", FEDSM2016-7735P (2016). 
15.    Peng, W. and Cao, X. "Numerical prediction of solid particle erosion in pipe bends with liquid–solid flow", Powder Technol. 294, 266–279 (2016). 
16.    Tu, J.Y., Fletcher, C.A.J., Behnia, M., Reizes, J.A., Owens, D. and Zones, P. "Prediction of flow and erosion in power utility boilers and comparison with measurement", J. Eng. Gas. Turb Power., 119(3), 709-716, (1999).
17.     Lee, B. E., Fletcher, C. A. J. and  Behnia, M. J.  "Computational Prediction of Tube Eosion in Coal Fired Power Utility Boilers", J. Eng. Gas. Turb. Power., 121(4), 746-750 (1999).
18.   Huttunen-Saarivirtaa, E., Kinnunen, H., Tuiremo, J., Uusitalo, M., Antonov, M. "Erosive wear of boiler steels by sand and ash", Wear, 317, 213–224 (2014).
19.   Goosen, P. and Malgas, I. "An Experimental Investigation into Aspects of Wear in Boiler Ash Disposal Pipelines", 14th Int Conf Slurry Handel Pipeline Transp. 8–10 (1999).
20.    Das, S.K., Godiwalla, K.M., Mehrotra, S.P., Sastry, K.K.M. and Dey, P.K.  "Analytical model for erosion behaviour of impacted fly-ash particles on coal-fired boiler components", Sadhana, 31(5), 583–595 (2006).
21.    Singh, G., Kumar, S. and Mohapatra, S.K. "Erosion Wear in A Slurry Pipe With Multisized Coal And Bottom-Ash Slurries", Mater. Today Proc., 4, 3565-3571 (2017).
22.     Singh, J., Kumar, S., Singh, J.P., Kumar, P. and Mohapatra, S.K.  "CFD modeling of erosion wear in pipe bend for the flow of bottom ash suspension", Particul. Sci. Technol., 37(3), 275-285 (2019). .
23.      Kannojiya, V., Darshan, M. B. and Chandra, Y.P. "Numerical analysis of erosion wear and pressure drop for turbulent multiphase slurry flow." Arch, Mech. Eng., 65(3), 361-378 (2018).
24.     Fluent I, “Fluent 6.3 User Guide,” Fluent Inc., Lebanon, 2002.
25.   Morsi, S.A. and Alexander, A.J. "An investigation of particle trajectories in two-phase flow systems". J Fluid Mech. 52(2),193–208 (1972).
26.   Edwards, J.K. "Development, Validation, and Application of a Three Dimension, CFD-Based Erosion Prediction Procedure",  Ph.D. Thesis, The University of Tulsa, Tulsa, (2000).
27.     Safaei, M. R., Mahian, O., Garoosi, F., Hooman, K., Karimipour, A., Kazi, S. N. and Gharehkhani, S. "Investigation of Micro- and Nanosized Particle Erosion in a 90° Pipe Bend Using a Two-Phase Discrete Phase Model", Sci. World J., Volume 2014, Article ID 740578, 12 pages
28.     Campos-Amezcua, A., Gallegos-Muñoz, A., Alejandro Romero, C., Mazur-Czerwiec, Z., Campos-Amezcua, R. "Numerical investigation of the solid particle erosion rate in a steam turbine nozzle", Appl.Therm. Engi., 27, 2394-2403 (2007).
29.   Kamarudin, N. H., Prasada Rao A K, Azhari, A. "CFD Based Erosion Modelling of Abrasive Waterjet Nozzle using Discrete Phase Method". IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 114 (2016) 012016.
30.    Bozzini, B., Ricotti, M. E., Boniardi, M. and Mele, C. "Evaluation of erosion-corrosion in multiphase flow via CFD and experimental analysis". Wear, 255, 237–45 (2003). doi:10.1016/s0043-1648(03)00181-9.
31.     Cotton, K.C. "Evaluating and Improving Steam Turbine Performance", Cotton Fact Inc., New York, (1993).
32.  Shamshirband, S., Malvandi, A., Karimipour, A., Goodarzi, M., Afrand et al. "Performance investigation of micro- and nano-sized particle erosion in a 90° elbow using an ANFIS model", Powder Technol., 284, 336–343 (2015).
33.     Habib, M.A., Badr, H.M. and Kabir, M.E. "Erosion and penetration rates of a pipe protruded in a sudden contraction", Compt. Fluids., 37, 146–160 (2008).