A comparative analysis of the new excitation controlled synchronous generator-based wind turbine

Document Type : Article


Department of Electrical Engineering, Sharif University of Technology, Tehran, Iran


Excitation Controlled Synchronous Generator-based Wind Turbine (ECSG WT) is a recently proposed wind turbine scheme which has not been fully investigated in detail. This paper is devoted to analyze performance of the ECSG WT scheme and to compare it with two mainstream wind turbine schemes based on electrically excited synchronous generator, i.e. VSC-based full converter wind turbine and diode bridge rectifier-based wind turbine equipped with boost converter on its DC link. The aim of this comparison is to demonstrate great potentials of ECSG WT for being considered in wind industry. To do so, two successful WT schemes at the market which are structurally close to ECSG WT are selected. The comparison includes different technical and economic aspects of the three schemes, assuming DC grid connection for the wind turbines. In addition, another comparison is made between the recently introduced Siemens 2nd generation DC Grid Access Offshore wind farm and a wind farm with similar structure, but using ECSG WTs. The results of these comparisons declare that ECSG WT scheme has promising characteristics, especially regarding economic, reliability and efficiency aspects.


1. Liserre, M., Cardenas, R., Molinas, M., et al."Overview of multi-MW wind turbines and wind parks", Industrial Electronics, IEEE Trans. on, 58(4), pp. 1081-1095 (2011).
2. Anaya-Lara, O., O. Tande, J., Uhlen, K., et al. "Energy conversion systems for offshore wind turbines", In Offshore Wind Energy Technology, 1st Ed., pp. 13-34 John Wiley & Sons (2018).
3. Al-Bahadly, I.H., Wind Turbine Generators and Drives, In Wind Turbines, Ed. 1st, pp. 463-639, InTech, Rijeka, Croatia (2011).
4. Zhang, Z., Chen, A., Matveev, A., et al. "Highpower generators for offshore wind turbines", Energy Procedia, 35, pp. 52-61 (2013).
5. Lloberas, J., Sumper, A., Sanmarti, M., et al. "A review of high temperature superconductors for offshore wind power synchronous generators", Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 38, pp. 404-414 (2014).
6. Prada, M., Lgualada, L., Corchero, C., et al. "Hybrid AC-DC offshore wind power plant topology", Power Systems, IEEE Transactions on., 30(4), pp. 1868-1876 (2015).
7. Madariaga, A., Martin, J.L., Zamora, I., et al. "Technological trends in electric topologies for offshore wind power plants", Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 24, pp. 32-44 (2013).
8. Yaramasy, V., Wu, B., Sen, C., et al. "High-power wind energy conversion systems: State-of-the-art and emerging technologies", Proceedings of the IEEE, 103(5), pp. 740-788 (2015).
9. Polinder, H., Ferreira, J.A., Jensen, B., et al. "Trends in wind turbine generator systems", Emerging and Selected Topics in Power Electronics, IEEE Journal of, 1(3), pp. 174-185 (2013).
10. Ma, K., Tutelea, L., Boldea, I., et al. "Power electronic drives, controls, and electric generators for large wind turbines-an overview", Electric Power Components and Systems, 43(12), pp. 1406-1421 (2015).
11. Keysan, O. and Mueller, M.A. "A homopolar HTSG topology for large direct-drive wind turbines" Applied Superconductivity, IEEE Transactions on, 21(5), pp. 3523-3531 (2011).
12. Blaabjerg, F. and Ma, K. "Wind energy systems", Proceedings of the IEEE, 105(11), pp. 2116-2131 (2017).
13. Keysan, O., Radyjowski, P., Burchell, J., et al. "Towards more reliable and cost effective superconducting generators for wind turbines", Power Electronics, Machines and Drives (PEMD 2014), 7th IET International Conference, Manchester, UK (2014).
14. Wu, B., Lang, Y., Zargari, N., et al. "Wind energy system configurations", In Power Conversion and Control of Wind Energy Systems, 1st Ed., pp. 153-170, John Wiley & Sons, New Jersey, USA (2011).
15. Carrasco, J.M., Franquelo, L.G., Bialasiewicz, T., et al. "Power-electronic systems for the grid integration of renewable energy sources: A survey", IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, 53(4), pp. 1002-1016 (2006).
16. Arantegui, R.L., Corsatea, T., and Suomalainen, K."2012 JRC Wind Status Report", JRC Scientific and Policy Reports, Luxembourg, Office of the European Union, Institute for Energy and Transport (2013).
17. Shamsnia, A. and Parniani, M. "A new cost-effective wind farm structure with HVDC link preserving technical advantages of advanced offshore wind farms", (RE&PQJ-11) Renewable Energy and Power Quality Journal, 11, pp. 640-644 (2013).
18. Mueller, M. and Polinder, H. "Electrical drive technology", In Electrical Drives for Direct Drive Renewable Energy Systems, 1st Ed., pp. 1-130, Woodhead Publishing, Cambridge, UK (2013).
19. https://www.siemens.com/press/pool/de/events/2015/ energymanagement/2015-10-dc-grid/presentation-dcgrid-
20. https://www.infineon.com.
21. Poore, R. and Lettenmaier, T. "Alternative design study Report: Wind PACT advanced wind turbine drive train designs study", (NREL) National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Colorado, USA (2003).
22. Prabha Kundur, "Synchronous machine theory and modelling", In Power System Stability and Control, Ed. 1st , pp. 45-105, McGraw-Hill Inc. (1994).
23. Wheeler, P., Clare, J., Lillo, L., et al. "A reliability comparison of a matrix converter and an 18-pulse rectifier for aerospace applications", 12th Power Electronics and Motion Control Conf., Portoroz, Slovenia, pp. 496-500 (2006).
24. Song, Y. and Wang, B. "Survey on reliability of power electronic systems", Power Electronics, IEEE Transactions on, 28(1), pp. 591-604 (2013).
25. Military Handbook: Reliability Prediction of Electronic Equipment, Department of Defense, Washington DC. Tech, Rep. MIL-HDBK-217F (1991).
26. Howlader, A.M. and Senjyu, T. "A comprehensive review of low voltage ride through capability strategies for the wind energy conversion systems", Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 56, pp. 643-658 (2016).
27. Alepuz, S., Calle, A., Monge, S., et al. "Use of stored energy in PMSG rotor inertia for low-voltage ridethrough in back-to-back NPC converter-based wind power systems", Industrial Electronics, IEEE Transactions on, 60(5), pp. 1787-1796 (2013).
28. Tsili, M. and Papathanassiou, S. "A review of grid code technical requirements for wind farms", IET Renewable Power Generation, 3(3), pp. 308-332 (2009).
29. Nasiri, M., Milimonfared, J., and Fathi, S.H. "A review of low-voltage ride-through enhancement methods for permanent magnet synchronous generator based windturbines", Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 47, pp. 399-415 (2015).
30. Nasiri, M. and Mohammadi, R. "Peak current limitation for grid side inverter by limited active power in PMSG-based wind turbines during different grid faults", Sustainable Energy, IEEE Transactions on, 8(1), pp. 3-12 (2017).
31. https://www.galco.com.
32. http://www.reo.co.uk.
33. Grauers, A. "Synchronous generator and frequency converter in wind turbine applications: system design and efficiency", Technical report, School of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Chalmers University of Technology (1994).
34. Applying IGBTs, ABB handbook, Application Note 5SYA 2053-04 https://library.e.abb.com/public/ab119704d4797bc283257cd3002ac5e0/Applying%20IGB Ts 5SYA.
35. http://www.ptd.siemens.de/CIGRE2016 B3110 2nd generation DC GridAccess.pdf.