Comparative study of damage behavior of synthetic and natural fiber-reinforced brittle composite and natural fiber-reinforced flexible composite subjected to low-velocity impact

Document Type : Article


Department of Mechanical Engineering, National Institute of Technology Karnataka, Surathkal, Mangaluru 575025, India.


In the present study, comparative study on the damage behaviour of Glass-Epoxy (GE), Jute-Epoxy (JE) laminates with [0/90]s orientation and Jute-Rubber-Jute (JRJ) sandwich is carried out using ABAQUS/CAE finite element software. The GE, JE laminate and JRJ sandwich with thickness of 2 mm is impacted by a hemispherical shaped impactor at a velocity of 2.5 m/s. The mechanisms in which the brittle laminate gets damaged are analyzed using Hashin’s 2D failure criteria and flexible composites are analysed by ductile damage mechanism. The energy absorbed and the incipient point of each laminate was compared. It was observed from the results that there is no evidence of delamination in JRJ as opposed to GE and JE. The compliant nature of rubber contributes in absorbing more energy and it is slightly higher than GE. Also it was observed that there is no incipient point in JRJ sandwich which means there is no cracking of matrix since rubber is elastic material. Thus the JRJ material can be a better substitute for GE laminate in low velocity applications. The procedure proposed for the analysis in the present study can serve as benchmark method in modelling the impact behaviour of composite structures in further investigations.


Main Subjects

1. Friedrich, K. and Almajid, A.A. "Manufacturing aspects of advanced polymer composites for automotive applications", Applied Composite Materials, 20(2), pp. 107-128 (2013).
2. Dogan, A. and Arikan, V. "Low-velocity impact response of E-glass reinforced thermoset and thermoplastic based sandwich composites", Composites Part B: Engineering, 127, pp. 63-69 (2017).
3. Richardson, M.O.W. and Wisheart, M.J. "Review of low-velocity impact properties of composite materials", Composites Part A: Applied Science and Manufacturing, 27(12), pp. 1123-1131 (1996).
4. Jang, B.W. and Kim, C.G. "Real-time detection of low-velocity impact-induced delamination onset in composite laminates for eff:cient management of structural health", Composites Part B: Engineering, 123,pp. 124-135 (2017).
5. Yang, B.,Wang, Z., Zhou, L., Zhang, J., and Liang, W. "Experimental and numerical investigation of interply hybrid composites based on woven fabrics and PCBT resin subjected to low-velocity impact", Composite Structures, 132, pp. 464-476 (2015).
6. Yang, B., Wang, Z., Zhou, L., Zhang, J., Tong, L., and Liang, W. "Study on the low-velocity impact response and CAI behavior of foam-filled sandwich panels with hybrid facesheet", Composite Structures, 132, pp. 1129-1140 (2015).
7. Wu, J., Liu, X., Zhou, H., Li, L., and Liu, Z. "Experimental and numerical study on soft-hard-soft (SHS) cement based composite system under multiple impact loads", Materials and Design, 139, pp. 234-257 (2018).
8. Yang, B., He, L., and Gao, Y. "Simulation on impact response of FMLs: eect of fiber stacking sequence, thickness, and incident angle", Science and Engineering of Composite Materials, 25(3), pp. 621-631 (2017).
9. Zhang, C., Duodu, E.A., and Gu, J. "Finite element modeling of damage development in cross-ply composite laminates subjected to low velocity impact", Composite Structures, 173, pp. 219-227 (2017).
10. Abir, M.R., Tay, T.E., Ridha, M., and Lee, H.P. "On the relationship between failure mechanism and Compression After Impact (CAI) strength in composites", Composite Structures, 182, pp. 242-250 (2017).
11. Kling, S. and Czigany, T. "Damage detection and selfrepair in hollow glass fiber fabric reinforced epoxy composites via fiber filling", Composites Science and Technology, 99, pp. 82-88 (2014).
12. Wang, Z., Xu, L., Sun, X., Shi, M., and Liu, J. "Fatigue behavior of glass-fiber-reinforced epoxy composites embedded with shape memory alloy wires", Composite Structures, 178, pp. 311-319 (2017).
13. Almansour, F.A., Dhakal, H.N., and Zhang, Z.Y. "Eect of water absorption on Mode I interlaminar  fracture toughness of ax/basalt reinforced vinyl ester hybrid composites", Composite Structures, 168, pp. 813-825 (2017).
14. Wang, S., Huang, L., An, Q., Geng, L., and Liu, B. "Dramatically enhanced impact toughness of two-scale laminate-network structured composites", Materials and Design, 140, pp. 163-171 (2018).
15. Zhandarov, S. and Mader, E. "Determining the interfacial toughness from force-displacement curves in the pull-out and microbond tests using the alternative method", International Journal of Adhesion and Adhesives, 65, pp. 11-18 (2016).
16. Zheng, N., Huang, Y., Liu, H.Y., Gao, J., and Mai, Y.W. "Improvement of interlaminar fracture toughness in carbon fiber/epoxy composites with carbon nanotubes/ polysulfone interleaves", Composites Science and Technology, 140, pp. 8-15 (2017).
17. Sonnenfeld, C., Jakani, H.M., Agogue, R., Nunez, P., and Beauchene, P. "Thermoplastic/thermoset multilayer composites: A way to improve the impact damage tolerance of thermosetting resin matrix composites", Composite Structures, 171, pp. 298-305 (2017).
18. Wambua, P., Ivens, I., and Verpoest, I. "Natural fibers: can they replace glass in fibre reinforced plastics?", Composites Science and Technology, 63(9), pp. 1259- 1264 (2003).
19. Monteiro, S.N., Lopes, F.P.D., Ferreira, A.S., and Nascimento, D.C.O. "Natural fiber polymer matrix composites: cheaper, tougher and environmentally friendly", JOM, 61(1), pp. 17-22 (2009).
20. Holbery, J. and Houston, D. "Natural-fiber-reinforced polymer composites applications in automotive", JOM, 58(11), pp. 80-86 (2006). 
21. Thomas, N., Paul, S.A., Pothan, L.A., and Deepa, B., Natural Fibers: Structure, Properties and Applications, Springer-Verlag Publications, Berlin, pp. 3-42 (2011).
22. Satyanarayana, K.G., Guimaraes, J.L., and Wypych, F. "Studies on lingo cellulosic fibers of Brazil. Part I: Source, production, morphology, properties and applications", Composites Part A Applied Science and Manufacturing, 38(7), pp. 1694-1709 (2007).
23. Ariatapeh, M.Y., Mashayekhi, M., and Rad, S.Z. "Prediction of all-steel CNG cylinder fracture under impact using a damage mechanics approach", Scientia Iranica, Transactions B, 21(3), pp. 609-619 (2014).
24. Vishwas, M., Joladarashi, Sh., and Kulkarni, S.M. "Investigation on effect of using rubber as core material in sandwich composite plate subjected to low velocity normal and oblique impact loading", Scientia Iranica, Transactions B, 26 (2), pp. 897-907 (2019). DOI: 10.24200/sci.2018.5538.1331.
25. Karas, K. "Plates under lateral impact", Archive of Applied Mechanics, 10, pp. 237-250 (1939). 
26. Hyunbum, P. "Investigation on low velocity impact behavior between graphite/epoxy composite and steel plate", Composite Structures, 171, pp. 126-130 (2017).
27. Khan, S.H., Sharma, A.P., and Parameswaran, V. "An Impact induced damage in composite laminates with intra-layer and inter-laminate damage", Procedia Engineering, 173, pp. 409-416 (2017).
28. Zhang, C., Duodu, E.A., and Gu, J. "Finite element modeling of damage development in cross-ply composite laminates subjected to low velocity impact", Composite Structures, 173, pp. 219-227 (2017).
29. Rajole, S., Kumar, N., Ravishankar, K.S., and Kulkarni, S.M. "Mechanical characterization and finite element analysis of jute-epoxy composite", MATEC Web of Conferences, 144 (2018).
30. Lee, S.M., Handbook of Composite Reinforcement, Wiley publications, Palo Alto, California, USA (1992). 
31. Mir, A., Aribi, C., and Bezzazi, B. "Study of the green composite jute/epoxy", International Journal of Chemical, Molecular, Nuclear, Materials and Metallurgical Engineering, 8(2), pp. 182-186 (2014).
32. Hossain, M.R., Islam, M.A., Vuurea, A.V., and Verpoest, I. "Eect of fiber orientation on the tensile properties of jute epoxy laminated composite", Journal of Scientific Research, 5(1), pp. 43-54 (2013).
33. Lopes, C.S., Camanho, P.P., Grdal, Z., Maim, P., and Gonzlez, E.V. "Low-velocity impact damage on dispersed stacking sequence laminates. Part II: Numerical simulations", Composites Science and Technology, 69(7-8), pp. 937-947 (2009).
34. Schn, J. "Coeff:cient of friction of composite delamination surfaces", Wear, 237(1), pp. 77-89 (2000).