Numerical modeling of sand particle erosion at return bends in gas-particle two-phase flow

Document Type : Article


1 Department of Mechanical Engineering, Amirkabir University of Technology, Tehran, Iran

2 Energy Reseach Center, Amirkabir university of technology

3 Mechanical and Aeronautical Engineering, Clarkson University, Potsdam, New York, USA


In gas and oil industry, erosion damages to pipe lines bends and elbows due to the presence of sand particles have been a challenging issue. In this study a computational model approach was for evaluating the erosion rates in different vertical return bends including sharp bend, standard elbow, 180° pipe bend and long elbow. The airflow in the pipe was simulated using the SIMPLE method and the k-ω SST turbulence model. An Eulerian-Lagrangian approach was used for predicting particle trajectories and the corresponding erosion rates. Different particle sizes and mass flow rates were considered and Oka model for evaluating the erosion rate was used in these simulations. Under the same conditions, the simulation results indicated that the sharp return bends experience the highest erosion rates and the 180° bends experience the lowest erosion among the studied configurations. It was also found that the erosion rate is linearly proportional to the mass flow rate of particles for all cases studied.


Main Subjects

1. True, M.E. and Weiner, P.D. \A laboratory evaluation
of sand erosion of oil gas well producing equipment",
In Annual Meeting Papers, Division of Production,
American Petroleum Institute (1976).
2. Mansouri, A. \A combined CFD-experimental method
for developing an erosion equation for both gas-sand
and liquid-sand
ows", E/CRC, The University of
Tulsa (2016).
3. Shirazi, S.A., McLaury, B.S., Sow, E., Butter, M.K.,
Folefac, A.N., and Hassaballa, S. \Sand settling and
locations of high erosion in subsea production system",
In Trinidad and Tobago Energy Resources Conference,
Society of Petroleum Engineers (2010).
4. Finnie, I. \Erosion of surfaces by solid particles",
Wear, 3(2), pp. 87-103 (1960).
5. Bitter, J.G.A. \A study of erosion phenomena, Part
I", Wear, 6(1), pp. 5-21 (1963).
6. Sheldon, G.L. and Finnie, I. \On the ductile behavior
of nominally brittle materials during erosive cutting",
Journal of Engineering for Industry, 88(4), pp. 387-
392 (1966).
7. American Petroleum Institute. Production Dept. \API
recommended practice for design and installation of
o shore production platform piping systems", American
Petroleum Institute (1981).
8. Salama, M.M. and Venkatesh, E.S. \Evaluation of API
RP 14E erosional velocity limitations for o shore gas
wells", In O shore Technology Conference (1983).
9. Russell, R., Shirazi, S., and Macrae, J. \A new computational

uid dynamics model to predict
ow pro les
and erosion rates in downhole completion equipment",
In SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition,
Society of Petroleum Engineers (2004).
10. Shirazi, S.A. \Threshold Velocities How fast can you

ow and still avoid sand erosion problem", E/CRC,
The University of Tulsa (1994).
11. Chen, X., McLaury, B.S., and Shirazi, S.A. \E ects of
applying a stochastic rebound model in erosion prediction
of elbow and plugged tee", In ASME 2002 Joint
US-European Fluids Engineering Division Conference,
pp. 247-254 (2002).
12. Grant, G. and Tabako , W. \Erosion prediction in
turbomachinery resulting from environmental solid
particles", Journal of Aircraft, 12(5), pp. 471-478
13. Oka, Y.I., Okamura, K., and Yoshida, T. \Practical
estimation of erosion damage caused by solid particle
impact: Part 1: E ects of impact parameters on
a predictive equation", Wear, 259(1-6), pp. 95-101
14. Abdulla, A. \Estimating erosion in oil and gas pipe
line due to sand presence", Master Thesis, Blekinge
Institute of Technology, Karlskrona, Sweden (2011).
15. Mazumder, Q.H. \E ect of liquid and gas velocities
on magnitude and location of maximum erosion in Ubend",
Open Journal of Fluid Dynamics, 2(2), p. 29
16. Mazumder, Q.H. \S-bend erosion in particulated multiphase

ow with air and sand", The Journal of
Computational Multiphase Flows, 8(3), pp. 157-166
17. Pereira, G.C., de Souza, F.J., and de Moro Martins,
D.A. \Numerical prediction of the erosion due to
particles in elbows", Powder Technology, 261, pp. 105-
117 (2014).
18. Ahlert, K.R. \E ects of particle impingement angle
and surface wetting on solid particle erosion of AISI
1018 steel", Doctoral Dissertation, University of Tulsa
19. Neilson, J.H. and Gilchrist, A. \Erosion by a stream
of solid particles", Wear, 11(2), pp. 111-122 (1968).
20. Zhang, Y., Reuterfors, E.P., McLaury, B.S., Shirazi,
S.A., and Rybicki, E.F. \Comparison of computed and
measured particle velocities and erosion in water and
ows", Wear, 263(1-6), pp. 330-338 (2007).
21. Oka, Y.I., Ohnogi, H., Hosokawa, T., and Matsumura,
M. \The impact angle dependence of erosion damage
caused by solid particle impact", Wear, 203, pp. 573-
579 (1997).
22. Fan, J.R., Luo, K., Zhang, X.Y., and Cen, K.C. \Large
eddy simulation of the anti-erosion characteristics of
the ribbed-bend in gas-solid
ows", Journal of Engineering
for Gas Turbines and Power, 126(3), pp. 672-
679 (2004).
3242 A. Farokhipour et al./Scientia Iranica, Transactions B: Mechanical Engineering 25 (2018) 3231{3242
23. Chen, J., Wang, Y., Li, X., He, R., Han, S., and Chen,
Y. \Erosion prediction of liquid-particle two-phase
in pipeline elbows via CFD-DEM coupling method",
Powder Technology, 275, pp. 182-187 (2015).
24. Mansouri, A., Arabnejad, H., Karimi, S., Shirazi,
S.A., and McLaury, B.S. \Improved CFD modeling
and validation of erosion damage due to ne sand
particles", Wear, 338, pp. 339-350 (2015).
25. Vieira, R.E., Mansouri, A., McLaury, B.S., and Shirazi,
S.A. \Experimental and computational study of
erosion in elbows due to sand particles in air
Powder Technology, 288, pp. 339-353 (2016).
26. Zahedi, P., Karimi, S., Mahdavi, M., McLaury, B.S.,
and Shirazi, S.A. \Parametric analysis of erosion in 90
degree and long radius bends", In ASME 2016 Fluids
Engineering Division Summer Meeting Collocated with
the ASME 2016 Heat Transfer Summer Conference
and the ASME 2016 14th International Conference
on Nanochannels, Microchannels, and Minichannels,
American Society of Mechanical Engineers (2016).
27. Duarte, C.A.R., de Souza, F.J., and dos Santos, V.F.
\Mitigating elbow erosion with a vortex chamber",
Powder Technology, 288, pp. 6-25 (2016).
28. Zheng, C., Liu, Y., Wang, H., Zhu, H., Liu, Z.,
Cai, B., and Shen, Y. \Numerical study on improving
the erosion life of ball seat for oil and gas reservoir
fracturing", Engineering Failure Analysis, 60, pp. 188-
198 (2016).
29. Zehtabiyan-Rezaie, N., Zarandi, F., Hossein, M., and
Sa ar-Avval, M. \Generalized heat transfer and entropy
generation of strati ed air-water
ow in entrance
of a mini-channel", Scientia Iranica, 24(5), pp. 2407-
2417 (2017).
30. Banakermani, M.R., Naderan, H., and Sa ar-Avval,
M. \An investigation of erosion prediction for 15 to
90 elbows by numerical simulation of gas-solid
Powder Technology, 334, pp. 9-26 (2018).
31. Fluent AN. 18.2, Theory Guide, ANSYS Inc. Canonsburg,
PA (2017).
32. Sajjadi, H., Salmanzadeh, M., Ahmadi, G., and Jafari,
S. \Investigation of particle deposition and dispersion
using Hybrid LES/RANS model based on lattice Boltzmann
method", Scientia Iranica, 25(6) (2018). DOI:
33. Parsi, M., Agrawal, M., Srinivasan, V., Vieira, R.E.,
Torres, C.F., McLaury, B.S., and Shirazi, S.A. \CFD
simulation of sand particle erosion in gas-dominant
ow", Journal of Natural Gas Science and
Engineering, 27, pp. 706-718 (2015).
34. Haider, A. and Levenspiel, O. \Drag coecient and
terminal velocity of spherical and nonspherical particles",
Powder Technology, 58(1), pp. 63-70 (1989).
35. Veritas, D.N. \Recommended Practice RP O501 erosive
wear in piping systems", DNV Recommended
Practice, 4 (2007).
36. Enayet, M.M., Gibson, M.M., Taylor, A.M.K.P., and
Yianneskis, M. \Laser-Doppler measurements of laminar
and turbulent
ow in a pipe bend", International
Journal of Heat and Fluid Flow, 3(4), pp. 213-219
37. Wang, J. and Shirazi, S.A. \A CFD based correlation
for erosion factor for long-radius elbows and bends",
Journal of Energy Resources Technology, 125(1), pp.
26-34 (2003).