An architectural solution for virtual computer integrated manufacturing systems using ISO standards

Document Type : Article


Department of Industrial Engineering, Advanced Manufacturing Laboratory, Sharif University of Technology, Tehran, Iran


Nowadays, manufacturing environments are faced with globalization which urges new necessities for manufacturing systems. These necessities have been considered from different perspectives and Computer Integrated Manufacturing (CIM) is the most popular and effective one. However, considering rapid rate of manufacturing globalization, traditional and current CIM solutions can be criticized by major deficiencies like high complexity for resource allocation over the globe, global facility sharing, and absence of an efficient way to handle lifecycle issues. Recently, Virtual CIM (VCIM) has been introduced as an effective solution to extend the traditional CIM solutions. This paper has investigated recent researches in VCIM/CIM field considering the necessities of todays’ globalized manufacturing environment. The paper shows the lack of traditional and current CIM/VCIM solutions; then, proposes an effective solution to cover them. Because of the complexities in designing such systems, the paper exploits Axiomatic Design (AD) Theory as a promising tools in this field. This theory is applied for validation of the suggested architectural solution and verification of the implementational aspects. The implementation of the architectural solution is considered based on ISO standards. Finally, the results have approved the feasibility of the suggested solution for manufacturing system and its Implementation aspects.


Main Subjects

1. Valilai, O.F. and Houshmand, M. "A collaborative and integrated platform to support distributed manufacturing system using a service-oriented approach based on cloud computing paradigm", Rob. and Com. Integ. Man., 29(1), pp. 110-127 (2013).
2. Koren, Y., The Global Manufacturing Revolution: Product-Process-Business Integration and Reconfigurable Systems, John Wiley & Sons, UK (2010).
3. Zhang, W. and Xie, S. "Agent technology for collaborative process planning: a review", The Int. J. of Adv. Man. Tech., 32(3), pp. 315-325 (2007).
4. Nagalingam, S.V. and Lin, G.C. "CIM-still the solution for manufacturing industry", Rob. and Com. Integ. Man., 24(3), pp. 332-344 (2008).
5. Houshmand, M. and Valilai, O.F. "LAYMOD: a layered and modular platform for CAx product data integration based on the modular architecture of the standard for exchange of product data", Int. J. of Com. Integ. Man., 25(6), pp. 473-487 (2012).
6. Valilai, O.F. and Houshmand, M. "INFELT STEP: An integrated and interoperable platform for collaborative CAD/CAPP/CAM/CNC machining systems based on STEP standard", Int. J. of Com. Integ. Man., 23(12), pp. 1095-1117 (2010).
7. Wang, X.V. and Xu, X.W. "An interoperable solution for cloud manufacturing", Rob. and Com. Integ. Man., 29(4), pp. 232-247 (2013).
8. Li, Q. "Applications integration in a hybrid cloud computing environment: modelling and platform", Ent. Info. Sys., 7(3), pp. 237-271 (2013).
9. Valilai, O.F. and Houshmand, M. "A platform for optimisation in distributed manufacturing enterprises based on cloud manufacturing paradigm", Int. J. of Com. Integ. Man., 27(11), pp. 1031-1054 (2014).
10. Houshmand, M. and Valilai, O.F. "A layered and modular platform to enable distributed CAx collaboration and support product data integration based on STEP standard", Int. J. of Com. Integ. Man., 26(8), pp. 731- 750 (2013).
11. Zhou, N. "Development of an agent based VCIM resource scheduling process for small and medium enterprises", Int. Ass. of Eng., 25(2), pp. 31-50 (2010).
12. Nagalingam, S.V. and Lin, G. "Latest developments in CIM", Rob. and Com. Integ. Man., 15(6), pp. 423-430 (1999).
13. Wang, D., Nagalingam, S., and Lin, G. "Development of an agent-based virtual CIM architecture for small to medium manufacturers", Rob. and Com. Integ. Man., 23, pp. 1-16 (2007).
14. Zhou, N., Nagalingam, S., and Lin, G. "Application of virtual CIM in small and medium manufacturing enterprises", Int. J. of Com. Integ. Man., 25(12), pp. 131-154 (2011).
15. Delaram, J. and Valilai, O.F. "Development of a novel solution to enable integration and interoperability for cloud manufacturing", Procedia CIRP, 52, pp. 6-11 (2016).
16. Scheer, A.W., CIM Computer Integrated Manufacturing: Computer Steered Industry, Springer Publishing Company (2012).
17. Rehg, J.A. and Kraebber, H.W., Computer-Integrated Manufacturing, Prentice Hall (2005).
18. McGaughey, R.E. and Roach, D. "Obstacles to computer integrated manufacturing success: a study of practitioner perceptions", Int. J. of Com. Integ. Man., 10(1), pp. 256-265 (1997).
19. Delaram, J. and Valilai, O.F. "A novel solution for manufacturing interoperability fulfillment using interoperability service providers", Procedia CIRP, 63, pp. 774-779 (2017).
20. Zhou, N. "Inside virtual CIM", Intel. Cont. and Com. Eng., 11(5), pp. 163-175 (2011).
21. Mitchell Jr, F., CIM Systems: An Introduction to Computer-Integrated Manufacturing, Prentice-Hall (1991) .
22. Groover, M.P., Automation, Production Systems, and Computer-Integrated Manufacturing, Prentice-Hall (2007).
23. Wang, X., Wong, T., and Wang, G. "An ontological intelligent agent platform to establish an ecological virtual enterprise", Exp. Sys. with App., 39(8), pp. 7050-7061 (2012).
24. Nagalingam, S.V. and Lin, G. "A unified approach towards CIM justification", Com. Integ. Man. Sys., 10(2), pp. 133-145 (1997).
25. Zhou, N. "Virtual CIM", Intel. Cont. and Com. Eng., 21(9), pp. 31-40 (2015).
26. Valilai, O.F. and Houshmand, M. "Depicting additive manufacturing from a global perspective; using cloud manufacturing paradigm for integration and collaboration", Pro. of the Inst. of Mech. Eng., Part B: J. of Eng. Man., 229(12), pp. 2216-2237 (2014).
27. Erenay, O., Hashemipour, M., and Kayaligil, S. "Virtual reality in requirement analysis for CIM system development suitable for SMEs", Int. J. of Pro. Res., 40(15), pp. 3693-3708 (2002).
28. Nagalingam, S., Lin, G., and Wang, D. "Resource scheduling for a virtual CIM system", Adv. Man., 10(2), pp. 269-294 (2007).
29. Zhou, N., Nagalingam, S., and Lin, G. "Application of virtual CIM in small and medium manufacturing enterprises", Int. J. of Pro. Res., 9(4), pp. 161-164 (2007).
30. Browne, J., The Extended Enterprise-Manufacturing and the Value Chain, Springer (1995).
31. Jagdev, H. and Browne, J. "The extended enterprisea context for manufacturing", Pro. Plan. and Cont., 9(3), pp. 216-229 (1998).
32. Martinez, M.T. "Virtual enterprise-organisation, evolution and control", Int. J. of Pro. Eco., 74(1), pp. 225-238 (2001).
33. Park, K.H. and Favrel, J. "Virtual enterpriseinformation system and networking solution", Com. and Ind. Eng., 37(1), pp. 441-444 (1999).
34. Liu, N., Li, X., and Shen, W. "Multi-granularity resource virtualization and sharing strategies in cloud manufacturing", J. of Net. and Com. App., 46, pp. 72-82 (2014).
35. Morariu, O., Borangiu, T., and Raileanu, S. "vMES: Virtualization aware manufacturing execution system", Comp. in Ind., 67(2), pp. 27-37 (2015).
36. Buyya, R., Vecchiola, C., and Selvi, S.T. "Virtualization, in mastering cloud computing", Comp. in Ind., 67(2), pp. 71-109 (2013).
37. Van Geenhuizen, M. and Nijkamp, P. "Knowledge virtualization and local connectedness among young globalized high-tech companies", Tech. Fore. and Soc. Chan., 79(7), pp. 1179-1191 (2012).
38. Camarinha-Matos, L.M. and Afsarmanesh, H. "A comprehensive modeling framework for collaborative networked organizations", J. of Intel. Man., 18(5), pp. 529-542 (2007).
39. Brown, E.A. "Reinventing government research and development: A status report on management initiatives and reinvention efforts at the Army Research Laboratory", J. of Net. and Com. App., 62(1), pp. 78-111 (1998).
40. Vassiliou, M. "The virtual research laboratory: taxonomy and analysis. in aerospace", Com. and Ind. Eng., 37(1), pp. 441-444 (1999).
41. Narula, R. "R&D collaboration by SMEs: new opportunities and limitations in the face of globalisation", Techno., 24(2), pp. 153-161 (2004).
42. Ross, J.W., Weill, P., and Robertson, D. "Enterprise architecture as strategy: Creating a foundation for business execution", Har. Bus. Rev., 65(3), pp. 34-44 (2006).
43. Browne, J. and Zhang, J. "Extended and virtual enterprises-similarities and differences", Int. J. of Ag. Man. Sys., 1(1), pp. 30-36 (1999).
44. Zhang, J., Chan, F., and Li, P. "Agent-and  ORBAbased application integration platform for an agile manufacturing environment", The Int. J. of Adv. Man. Tech., 21(6), pp. 460-468 (2003).
45. Huang, B. "A framework for virtual enterprise control with the holonic manufacturing paradigm", Com. In Ind., 49(3), pp. 299-310 (2002).
46. Odrey, N.G. and Meji, G. "A re-configurable multiagent system architecture for error recovery in production systems", Rob. and Com. Integ. Man., 19(1), pp. 35-43 (2003).
47. Hernandez-Matias, J. "An integrated modelling framework to support manufacturing system diagnosis for continuous improvement", Rob. and Com. Iinteg. Man., 24(2), pp. 187-199 (2008).
48. Lin, C.P. and Jeng, M. "An expanded SEMATECH CIM framework for heterogeneous applications integration", Man. and Cyber., 36(1), pp. 76-90 (2006).
49. Nahm, Y.E. and Ishikawa, H. "A hybrid multi-agent system architecture for enterprise integration using computer networks", Rob. and Com. Integ. Man., 21(3), pp. 217-234 (2005).
50. Williamson, A. and Deasley, P. "Systems thinking and computer-integrated manufacturing", Sys. Prac Tech., 7(1), pp. 9-23 (1994).
51. Trappey, A.J., Liu, T.H., and Hwang, C.T. "Using EXPRESS data modeling technique for PCB assembly analysis", Com. In Ind., 34(1), pp. 111-123 (1997).
52. Delaram, J. and Valilai, O.F. "An architectural view to computer integrated manufacturing systems based on axiomatic design theory", Com. In Ind., 100, pp. 96-114 (2018).
53. Suh, N.P., The Principles of Design, Oxford University Press, UK (1990).
54. Kulak, O. and Kahraman, C. "Fuzzy multi-attribute selection among transportation companies using axiomatic design and analytic hierarchy process", Info. Sci., 170(2), pp. 191-210 (2005).
55. Carnevalli, J.A., Miguel, P.A.C., and Calarge, F.A. "Axiomatic design application for minimising the difficulties of QFD usage", Int. J. of Pro. Eco., 125(1), pp. 1-12 (2010).
56. Peck, J., Nightingale, D., and Kim, S.G. "Axiomatic approach for efficient healthcare system design and optimization", CIRP Ann. Man. Tech., 59(1), pp. 469- 472 (2010).
57. Linke, B.S. and Dornfeld, D.A. "Application of axiomatic design principles to identify more sustainable strategies for grinding", J. of Man. Sys., 52(4), pp. 49-72 (2012).
58. Cochran, D.S. "The application of axiomatic design and lean management principles in the scope of production system segmentation", Int. J. of Pro. Res., 38(6), pp. 1377-1396 (2000).
59. Valilai, O.F. and Houshmand, M. "A manufacturing ontology model to enable data integration services in cloud manufacturing using axiomatic design theory", in Cloud-Based Design and Manufacturing (CBDM): A Service-Oriented Product Development Paradigm for the 21st Century, Springer (2014).
60. Suh, N.P., Axiomatic Design: Advances and Applications, Oxford University Press, UK (2001).
61. Kim, S.J., Suh, N.P., and Kim, S.G. "Design of software systems based on axiomatic design", Rob. and Com. Integ. Man., 8(4), pp. 243-255 (1991).
62. Rechtin, E., Systems Architecting: Creating and Building Complex Systems, Prentice-Hall (2001).
63. Albano, L.D. and Suh, N.P. "Axiomatic design and concurrent engineering", Com. Aid. Des., 26(7), pp. 499-504 (1994).
64. Bae, S., Lee, J.M., and Chu, C.N. "Axiomatic design of automotive suspension systems", CIRP Ann. Man. Tech., 51(1), pp. 115-118 (2002).
65. Suh, N.P. "Designing-in of quality through axiomatic design", Rel, Trans., 44(2), pp. 256-264 (1995).
66. Goncalves-Coelho, A.M. and Mourao, A.J. "Axiomatic design as support for decision-making in a design for manufacturing context: A case study", Int. J. of Pro. Eco., 109(1), pp. 81-89 (2007).
67. Cebi, S. and Kahraman, C. "Indicator design for p passenger car using fuzzy axiomatic design principles", Exp. Sys. with App., 37(9), pp. 6470-6481 (2010).
68. Suh, N.P. "Axiomatic design of mechanical systems", J. of Mech. Des., 117(B), pp. 2-10 (1995). 
69. Gebala, D.A. and Suh, N.P. "An application of axiomatic design", Res. in Eng. Des., 3(3), pp. 149-162 (1992).
70. Togay, C., Dogru, A.H., and Tanik, J.U. "Systematic component-oriented development with axiomatic design", J. of Sys. and Soft., 81(11), pp. 1803-1815 (2008).
71. Ferrer, I. "Methodology for capturing and formalizing DFM Knowledge", Rob. and Com. Integ. Man., 26(5), pp. 420-429 (2010).
72. Cebi, S., Celik, M., and Kahraman, C. "Structuring ship design project approval mechanism towards installation of operator-system interfaces via fuzzy axiomatic design principles", Info. Sci., 180(6), pp. 886-895 (2010).
73. Heo, G. and Lee, S.K. "Design evaluation of emergency core cooling systems using axiomatic design", Nuc. Eng. and Des., 237(1), pp. 38-46 (2007).
74. Thielman, J. "Evaluation and optimization of General Atomics' GT-MHR reactor cavity cooling system using an axiomatic design approach", Nuc. Eng. and Des., 235(13), pp. 1389-1402 (2005).
75. Yi, J.W. and Park, G.J. "Development of a design system for EPS cushioning package of a monitor using axiomatic design", Adv. in Eng. Soft., 36(4), pp. 273- 284 (2005).
76. Hirani, H. and Suh, N.P. "Bearing design using  ultiobjective genetic algorithm and axiomatic design approaches", Tri. Int., 38(5), pp. 481-491 (2005).
77. Janthong, N., Brissaud, D., and Butdee, S. "Combining axiomatic design and case-based reasoning in an innovative design methodology of mechatronics products", CIRP J. of Man. Sci. and Tech., 2(4), pp. 226-239 (2010).
78. catalogue/catalogue tc/ catalogue detail.htm?csnumber=39926.
79. catalogue/catalogue tc/ catalogue detail.htm?csnumber=29556.
80. catalogue/catalogue tc/ catalogue detail.htm?csnumber=24020.
81. catalogue/catalogue tc/ catalogue detail.htm?csnumber=28777.
82. catalogue/catalogue tc/ catalogue detail.htm?csnumber=50417.
83. detail.htm? csnumber=46559.
84. catalogue/catalogue tc/ catalogue detail.htm?csnumber=30418.
85. catalogue/catalogue tc/ catalogue detail.htm?csnumber=31583.
86. detail.htm? csnumber=57308.
87. detail.htm? csnumber=54497.