Mean bed shear stress estimation in a rough rectangular channel using a hybrid genetic algorithm based on an artificial neural network and genetic programming

Document Type : Article


Department of Civil Engineering, Razi University, Kermanshah, Iran


The determination of erosion and deposition patterns in channels requires detailed knowledge and estimations of the bed shear stress. In this investigation, the application of a Genetic Algorithm based Artificial (GAA) neural networkand genetic programming (GP) for predicting bed shear stress in a rectangular channel with rough boundaries. Several input combinations, fitness functions and transfer functions were investigated to determine the best GAA model. Also the effect of various GP operators on estimating bed shear stress was studied. The comparison between the GAA and GP technique abilities in predicting bed shear stress were investigated. The results revealed that the GAA model performs better in predicting the bed shear stress (RMSE = 0.0774), as compared to the GP model (RMSE = 0.0835).


Main Subjects

1.Knight,  D.W.,  Demetriou,  J.D.  and  Hamed,  M.E.Boundary shear in smooth rectangular channels",J.Hydraul. Eng.,10, pp. 405-422 (1984).2.Knight, D.W. Boundary shear in smooth and roughchannels",J. Hydraul. Div.,107, pp. 839-851 (1981).3.Tominaga,  A.,  Nezu,  I.,  Ezaki,  K.  and  Nakagawa,H. Three-dimensional turbulent structure in straightopen channel  ows",J. Hydraul. Res.,27, pp. 149-173(1989).4.Bonakdari,   H.,   Tooshmalani,   M.   and   Sheikh,   Z.Predicting  shear  stress  distribution  in  rectangularchannels using entropy concept",Int.  J.  Eng.,28(3),pp. 357-364 (2015).5.Alhamid, A.A.I. Boundary shear stress and velocitydistributions  in  di erentially  roughened  trapezoidalopen channels", PhD Thesis, The University of Birm-ingham (1991).6.Sheikh, Z. and Bonakdari, H. Prediction of boundaryshear stress in circular and trapezoidal channels withEntropy concept",Urban Water J.,13(6), pp. 629-636(2015).7.Knight,  D.W.,  Yuen,  K.W.H.  and  Al  Hamid,  A.A.I.Boundary shear stress distributions in open channel ow", In:  K. Beven, P. Chatwin, J. Millbank (Eds.),Physical  Mechanisms  of  Mixing  and  Transport  in  theEnvironment, Wiley New York, pp. 51-87 (1994).8.Ardiclioglu, M., Sekcin, G. and Yurtal, R. Shear stressdistributions  along  the  cross  section  in  smooth  andrough  open  channel   ows",Kuwait  J.  Sci.  Eng.,33,pp. 155-68 (2006).9.Guo, J. and Julien, P.Y. Shear stress in smooth rect-angular open-channel  ow",J. Hydraul. Eng.,131(1),pp. 30-37 (2005).10.Babaeyan-Koopaei,  K.,  Ervine,  D.A.,  Carling,  P.A.and  Cao,  Z.  Velocity  and  turbulence  measurementsfor  two  overbank   ow  events  in  River  Severn",J.Hydraul. Eng.,128, pp. 891-900 (2002).11.Julien,  P.Y.,Erosion  and  Sedimentation,  U.K.  Cam-bridge University Press (1995).12.Berlamont,  J.E.,  Trouw,  K.  and  Luyckx,  G.  Shearstress distribution in partially  lled pipes",J. Hydraul.Eng.,129(9), pp. 697-705 (2003).13.Han, Y., Yang, S.Q. and Dharmasiri, N. Applicationof  main   ow  data  in  the  determination  of  boundaryshear  stress  in  smooth  closed  ducts",World  Envi-ronmental  and  Water  Resources  Congress:   CrossingBoundaries, Albuquerque, NM (2012).14.Yang, S.Q., Dharmasiri, N. and Han, Y. Momentumbalance  method  and  estimation  of  boundary  shearstress  distribution",J.  Hydraul.  Eng.,138,  pp.  657-660 (2012).15.Knight,  D.W.  and  Sterling,  M.  Boundary  shear  incircular pipes partially full",J. Hydraul. Eng.,126(4),pp. 263-275 (2000).16.Bonakdari, H., Sheikh, Z. and Tooshmalani, M. Com-parison  between  Shannon  and  Tsallis  entropies  forprediction of shear stress distribution in circular openchannels",Stoch.  Env.  Res.  Risk  Assess.,29(1),  pp.1-11 (2015).17.Sheikh Khozani, Z., Bonakdari, H. and Ebtehaj, I. Ananalysis of shear stress distribution in circular channelswith  sediment  deposition  based  on  gene  expressionprogramming",Int.  J.  Sediment  Res.(2017).  DOI:org/10.1016/j.ijsrc.2017.04.004 (2017).18.Gharagheizi, F., Ilani-Kashkouli, P., Farahani, N. andMohammadi,   A.H.  Gene  expression  programmingstrategy  for  estimation  of   ash  point  temperatureof  non-electrolyte  organic  compounds",Fluid  Phase.Equilibria.,329, pp. 71-77 (2012).19.Sheikh  Khozani,  Z.,  Bonakdari,  H.  and  Zaji,  A.H.Estimating  the  shear  stress  distribution  in  circularchannels  based  on  the  randomized  neural  networkstechnique",Appl. Soft Comp.,58, pp. 144-148 (2017).20.Najafzadeh, M., Barani, G.A. and Hessami Kermani,M.R.  GMDH  based  back  propagation  algorithm  topredict abutment scour in cohesive soils",Ocian Eng.,59, pp. 100-106 (2013).21.Kisi,  O.,  Emin  Emiroglu,  M.E.,  Bilhan,  O.  and  Gu-ven,  A. Prediction of lateral out ow over triangularlabyrinth side weirs under subcritical conditions usingsoft  computing  approaches",Expert  Syst.  Appl.,39,pp. 3454-3460 (2012).22.Shiri,  J.,  Ashraf  Sadraddini,  A.,  Nazemi,  A.H.,  Kisi,O.,  Landeras,  G.,  Fakheri  Fard,  A.  and  Marti,  P.Generalizability   of   gene   expression   programming-based approaches for estimating daily reference evap-otranspiration in coastal stations of Iran",J. Hydrol.,508, pp. 1-11 (2014).23.Sheikh  Khozani,  Z.,  Bonakdari,  H.  and  Zaji,  A.H.Using two soft computing methods in prediction walland bed shear stress in smooth rectangular channels",Appl.  Water  Sci.(2017).  DOI:  10.1007/s13201-017-0548-y (2017).24.Azamathulla,  H.M.  and  Zahiri,  A.  Flow  dischargeprediction in compound channels using linear geneticprogramming",J.   Hydrol.,454-455,   pp.   203-207(2012).25.Zaji, A.H. and Bonakdari, H. Performance evaluationof  two  di erent  neural  network  and  particle  swarmoptimization  methods  for  prediction  of  discharge  ca-pacity of modi ed triangular side weirs",Flow  Meas.Instrum.,40, pp. 149-156 (2014).26.Tayfur,  G.  Arti cial  neural  networks  for  sheet  sed-iment  transport",Hydrol.  Sci.  J.,47,  pp.  879-892(2002).27.Kisi,  O.,  Dailr,  A.H.,  Cimen,  M.  and  Shiri,  J.  Sus-pended sediment modeling using genetic programmingand soft computing techniques",J. Hydrol.,450-451,pp. 48-58 (2012).
Z. Sheikh Khozani et al./Scientia Iranica, Transactions A: Civil Engineering 25 (2018) 152{16116128.Cobaner,  M.,  Seckin,  G.,  Seckin,  N.  and  Yurtal,  R.Boundary shear stress analysis in smooth rectangularchannels  and  ducts  using  neural  networks",WaterEnviron. J.,24, pp. 133-139 (2010).29.Sheikh  Khozani,  Z.,  Bonakdari,  H.  and  Zaji,  A.M.Application of soft computing technique in predictionpercentage of shear force carried by walls in rectangu-lar channel with  non-homogenous roughness",WaterSci. Technol.,73(1), pp. 124-129 (2016).30.Sheikh  Khozani,  Z.,  Bonakdari,  H.  and  Zaji,  A.M.Application of a genetic algori