Closed loop supply chain network design for the paper industry: A multi-objective stochastic robust approach

Document Type : Article


1 Department of Industrial Engineering, Science and Research branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran

2 Department of Industrial Engineering, Alzahra University, Tehran, Iran

3 School of Industrial Engineering, College of Engineering, University of Tehran


Closed loop supply chain design is to provide an optimal platform for efficient and effective supply chain management. It is an essential and strategic operation management problem in supply chain management, and usually includes multiple and conflicting objectives. A new mixed integer non-linear programming model for a multi-objective closed loop supply chain network design problem in the paper industry is developed under uncertainty. The objective functions are to minimize the total cost, maximize the total volume flexibility and minimize the total number of vehicles hired in order to fulfill the paper industry’spolicies towards a cleaner and green environment. Also, a novel hybrid solution is presented based on stochastic programming, robust optimization and fuzzy goal programming. A numerical example utilizing the real data from the paper industry in East Azerbaijan of Iran is designed and the model performance is assessed. Furthermore, a recently developed Dragonfly Algorithm (DA) employed to solve the given problem in large scales and compared with Genetic Algorithm (GA). The results indicated that the DA achieved better performance compared with the GA.


Main Subjects

2. Yarahmadi, M., Salehi, N., and Salari, H. Practical
strategies to reduce the amount of paper consumption:
as study on Iranian paper industry", Indian Journal of
Fundamental and Applied Life Sciences, 4, pp. 2231-
6345 (2014).
3. Govindan, K., Soleimani, H., and Kannan, D. Reverse
logistics and closed-loop supply chain: A comprehensivereview
to explore the future", European Journal of
Operational Research, 240(3), pp. 603-626 (2015).
4. Uster, H., Easwaran, G., Akcali, E., and Cetinkaya,
S. Benders decomposition with alter-native multiple
cuts for a multi-product closed-loop supply chain
network design model", Naval Res Logist, 54, pp. 890-
907 (2007).
5. Fleischmann, M., Bloemhof-Ruwaard, J.M., Beullens,
P., and Dekker, R. Reverse logistics network design",
In Reverse Logistics: Quantitative Models for Closed-
Loop Supply Chains, R. Dekker, M. Fleischmann, K.
Inderfurth, & L.N. VanWassenhove, Eds., pp. 65-94,
Springer, Berlin (2004).
6. Du, F. and Evans, G.W. A bi-objective reverse logistics
network analysis for post-sale service", Computers
& Operations Research, 35, pp. 2617-2634 (2008).
7. Pishvaee, M.S., Farahani, R.Z., and Dullaert, W.A.
Memetic algorithm for bi-objective integrated forward/
reverse logistics network design", Computers &
Operations Research, 37(6), pp. 1100-1112 (2010).
8. Pishvaee, M.S. and Torabi, S.A.A. Possibilistic programming
approach for closed-loop supply chain network
design under uncertainty", Fuzzy Sets and Systems,
161, pp. 2668-2683 (2010).
9. Mirakhorli, A. Multi-objective optimization of reverse
logistics network with fuzzy demand and return- product
using an interactive fuzzy goal programming approach",
40th International Conference on Computers
and Industrial Engineering (CIE), pp. 1-6 (2010).
10. Khajavi, L.T., Seyed-Hosseini, S.M., and Makui, A.
An integrated forward/reverse logistics network optimization
model for multi-stage capacitated supply
chain", iBusiness, 3, pp. 229-35 (2011).
11. Zegordi, S.H., Eskandarpour, M., and Nikbakhsh, E.A.
Novel bi-objective multi-product post-sales reverse
logistics network design model", Proceedings of the
World Congress on Engineering (2011).
12. Zarandi, M.H.F., Sisakht, A.H., and Davari, S. Design
of a closed-loop supply chain model using an interactive
fuzzy goal programming", Int. J. Adv. Manuf.
Technol., 56, pp. 809-21 (2011).
13. Amin, S.H. and Zhang, G. A multi-objective facility
location model for closed-loop supply chain network
under uncertain demand and return", Applied Mathematical
Modelling, 37(6), pp. 4165-4176 (2013).
14.  Ozkr, V. and Baslgil, H. Multi-objective optimization
of closed-loop supply chains in uncertain environment",
Journal of Cleaner Production, 41, pp. 114-125
15. Subulan, K., Baykasoglu, A.,  Ozsoydan, F.B., Tasan,
A.S., and Selim, H.A. Case-oriented approach to a
lead/acid battery closed-loop supply chain network
design under risk and uncertainty", Journal of Manufacturing
Systems, 37, pp. 340-361 (2015).
16. Vahdani, B. and Mohamadi M. A bi-objective
interval-stochastic robust optimization model for designing
closed loop supply chain network with multipriority
queuing system", Intern. Journal of Production
Economics, 170, pp. 67-87 (2015).
17. Kadambala, D.K., Subramanian, N., Tiwari, M.K.,
Abdulrahman, M., and Liu, C. Closed loop supply
chain networks: Designs for energy and time value
eciency", Intern. Journal of Production Economics,
183, pp. 382-393 (2016).
18. Soleimani , H., Govindan, K., Sagha , H., and Jafari,
H. Fuzzy multi-objective sustainable and green
closed-loop supply chain network design", Computers
& Industrial Engineering, 109, pp. 191-203 (2017).
19. Paydar, M.M., Babaveisi, V., and Safaei, A.S. An
engine oil closed-loop supply chain design considering
collection risk", Computers & Chemical Engineering,
104, pp. 38-55 (2017).
20. Ucuncu, A. and Vesilind, P.A. Energy recovery from
mixed paper waste", Waste Manag. Res., 11, pp. 507-
513, (1993).
21. Slack, N. The
exibility of manufacturing systems",
Int. J. Oper. Prod Manag., 7, pp. 35-45 (1987).
22. Sabri, E.H. and Beamon, B.M. A multi-objective
approach to simultaneous strategic and operational
planning in supply chain design", Omega, 28, pp. 581-
98 (2000).
A. Rahmani Ahranjani et al./Scientia Iranica, Transactions E: Industrial Engineering 25 (2018) 2881{2903 2903
23. Subulan, K. Modelling strategic and tactical planning
problems in closed-loop supply chains under crisp and
fuzzy environments", Master's Thesis, University of
Dokuz Eylul, Izmir, Turkey (2012).
24. Vickery, S.N., Calantone, R., and Droge, C. Supply
exibility: An empirical study", J. Supply Chain
Manag., 35(3), pp. 16-24 (1999).
25. Garge, K., Kannan, D., Diabat, A., and Jha, P.C. A
multi-criteria optimization approach to manage environmental
issues in closed loop supply chain network
design", Journal of Cleaner Production, 100, pp. 297-
314 (2015).
26. Mirzapour Al-e-hashem, S.M.J., Malekly, H., and
Aryanezhad, M.B. A multi-objective robust optimization
model formulation product multi-site aggregate
production planning in a supply chain under uncertainty",
Int. J. Production Economics, 134, pp. 28-42
27. Ghodratnama, A., Tavakkoli-Moghaddam, R., and
Azaron, A. Robust and fuzzy goal programming
optimization approaches for a novel multi-objective
hub location-allocation problem: A supply chain
overview", Applied Soft Computing, 37, pp. 255-276
28. Syarif, A., Yun, Y., and Gen, M. Study on multistage
logistic chain network: A spanning tree-based
genetic algorithm approach", Computers & Industrial
Engineering, 43, pp. 299-314 (2002).
29. Devika, K., Jafarian, A., and Nourbakhsh, V. Designing
a sustainable closed-loop supply chain network
based on triple bottom line approach: A comparison
of metaheuristics hybridization techniques", Eur. J. of
Oper.Res., 235(3), pp. 594-615 (2014).
30. Mirjalili, S. Dragon
y algorithm: a new metaheuristic
optimization technique for solving singleobjective,
discrete, and multi-objective problems",
Neural Comput. & Applications, 27(4), pp. 1053-1073
(2015). DOI 10.1007/s00521-015-1920-1
31. John, H., Holland, Adaptation in Natural and Arti cial
Systems, MIT Press, Cambridge (1992).
32. Mulvey, J.M. and Ruszczynski, A. A new scenario
decomposition method for large-scale stochastic optimization",
Operations Research, 43, pp. 477-490