Multi-objective optimization design and performance evaluation of slotted Halbach PMSM using Monte Carlo method

Document Type : Article


1 University of 20 août 1955 Skikda, Department of Electrical Engineering, Skikda, Algeria

2 University of Tebessa, Department of Electrical Engineering, Tebessa, Algeria


This paper proposes the optimized design of the permanent magnet synchronous motor (PMSM) based on the analysis of radial-flux permanent magnet motor with minimum weight, maximum efficiency and an increased torque. The rotor of the PMSM uses segmented permanent magnets mounted on the surface. The achievement of the method involves four steps. Firstly, the simplified motor model is presented in a manner which yields symbolic solution for optimal motor parameters as a function of mass. Secondly, Monte Carlo method is employed to compute optimal motor dimensions giving efficiency, torque and optimal motor active mass. Then, the steady state characteristics of the optimized primary optimized design obtained in the last step are calculated and compared to satisfy the flux condition. Finally, the performance of the optimized machine has been calculated by using 2D transient finite-element analysis (FEA). Subsequently, the model mesh and the boundary conditions were handled and presented. According to the obtained results, the essential purpose of the work has been reached, the weight has been reduced by 24%, the efficiency was improved by 8% and the rated torque by 40%. The proposed design approach has also the advantage for its significant time reduction of the design cycle.


Main Subjects

1. Kroese, D.P., Taimre, T., and Botev, Z.I., Handbook of
Monte Carlo Methods, 706, John Wiley & Sons (2013).
2. Ismail, M.S., Moghavvemi, M., and Mahlia, T.M.I.
Genetic algorithm based optimization on modeling
and design of hybrid renewable energy systems", Energy
Conversion and Management, 85, pp. 120-130
3. Garca-Trivi~no, P., Llorens-Iborra, F., Garca-Vzquez,
C.A., Gil-Mena, A.J., Fernandez-Ramrez, L.M., and
Jurado, F. Long-term optimization based on PSO of
a grid-connected renewable energy/battery/hydrogen
hybrid system", International Journal of Hydrogen
Energy, 39(21), pp. 10805-10816 (2014).
4. Caner, M., Gerada, C., Asher, G., and  Ozer, T. Design
optimization of Halbach array permanent magnet
motor to achieve sensorless performance using genetic
algorithm", COMPEL-The International Journal for
Computation and Mathematics in Electrical and Electronic
Engineering, 35(5), pp. 1741-1759 (2016).
5. Duan, R., Harley, G., and Habetler, T.G. Multiobjective
design optimization of surface mount permanent
magnet machine with particle swarm intelligence",
IEEE Swarm Intelligence Symposium, pp. 1-5,
St. Louis, MO,21-23 (September 2008).
6. Jang, S.M., Jeong, S.S., Wan Ryu, D. and Choi,
S.K. Design and analysis of high speed slotless PM
machine with Halbach array", IEEE Trans. Magn.,
37(4), pp. 2827-2830 (July 2001).
7. Sadeghi, S. and Parsa, L. Multiobjective design
optimization of ve-phase halbach array permanentmagnet
machine", IEEE Transactions on Magnetics,
47(6), pp. 1658-1666 (June 2011).
8. Mardaneh, M., Mirsalim, M., and AliAhmadi, M. A
modi ed analytical approach in modelling and design
of axial-
ux permanent magnet machines", Amirkabir
(Electrical Engineering), 17 (2006).
9. Davood, A.K. and Amir, N. Design and simulation
of PWM recti er connected a PM generator of micro
turbine unit", Scientia Iranica D, 19(3), pp. 820-828
10. Hashemi, Z., Mardaneh, M., and Sha Sadeghi, M.
High performance controller for interior permanent
magnet synchronous motordrive using arti cial intelligence
methods", Scientia Iranica D, 19(6), pp. 1788-
1793 (2012).
11. Duan, Y., and Ionel, D.M. A review of recent developments
in electrical machine design optimization
methods with a permanent-magnet synchronous motor
benchmark study", IEEE Transactions on Industry
Applications, 49(3), pp. 1268-1275 (2013).
12. Wang, J., Howe, D. and Jewell, G.W. Analysis and
design optimization of an improved axially magnetized
tubular permanent-magnet machine", IEEE Transactions
on Energy Conversion, 19, pp. 289-295 (2004).
13. Markovic, M. and Perriard, Y. Optimization design of
a segmented Halbach permanent-magnet motor using
an analytical model", IEEE Trans. Magn., 45(7), pp.
2955-2960 (July 2009).
14. Zhu, Z.Q., Wu, L.J., and Xia, Z.P. An accurate subdomain
model for magnetic eld computation in slotted
surface-mounted permanent-magnet machines",
IEEE Trans. Magn., 46(4), pp. 1100-1115 (April
1544 I. Bouloukza et al./Scientia Iranica, Transactions D: Computer Science & ... 25 (2018) 1533{1544
15. Cassimere, B.N., Sudho , S.D., and Sudho , D.H.
Analytical design model for surface-mounted permanent
magnet synchronous machines", IEEE Trans.
Energy Convers., 24(2), pp. 347-357 (June 2009).
16. Vaez-Zadeh, S. and Ghasemi, A.R. Design optimization
of permanent magnet synchronous motors for high
torque capability and low magnet volume", Electr.
Power Sys. Res., 74(2), pp. 307-313 (2005).
17. Makni, Z., Besbes, M., and Marchand, C. Multiphysics
design methodology of permanent-magnet synchronous
motors", IEEE Trans. Veh. Technol., 56(4),
pp. 1524-1530 (July 2007).
18. Legranger, J., Friedrich, G., Vivier, S. and Mipo,
J.C. Combination of nite-element and analytical
models in the optimal multidomain design of machines:
Application to an interior permanent-magnet starter
generator", IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., 46(1), pp. 232-
239 (Jan./Feb. 2010).
19. Xia, Z.P., Zhu, Z.Q. and Howe, D. Analytical magnetic
eld analysis of halbach magnetized permanentmagnet
machines", IEEE Trans. Magn., 44(4), pp.
1864-1872 (Jul. 2004).
20. Stipetic, S., Zarko, D., and Kovacic, M. Optimised
design of permanent magnet assisted synchronous reluctance
motor series using combined analytical- nite
element analysis based approach", IET Electric Power
Applications, 10(5), pp. 330-338 (2016).
21. Senesky, M.K. Electromagnetic generators for
portable power applications", PHD Thesis University
of California, Berkeley (2005).
22. Zhu, Z.Q., and Howe, D. Instantaneous magnetic eld
distribution in permanent magnet brushless DC motors.
IV. Magnetic eld on load", IEEE Transactions
on Magnetics, 29(1), pp. 152-158 (1993).
23. Pinkham, A.P. Modeling and optimization of permanent
magnet motors", Doctoral Dissertation, Massachusetts
Institute of Technology (2008).