A New Method for Three Dimensional Stability Analysis of Earth Slopes

Document Type : Article


1 Department of Civil Engineering, Razi University, Taghe Bostan, P.O. Box 67149-67346, Kermanshah, Iran

2 Department of Civil Engineering, M.Sc Student, Razi University, Taghe Bostan, P.O. Box 67149-67346, Kermanshah, Iran

3 Department of Civil Engineering, Imam Khomeini International University, P.O. Box 34148-96818, Qazvin, Iran


In this research, a new three-dimensional limit equilibrium method was developed. In the proposed method, the slip surface was assumed to be spherical and slices were assumed along the slip surface radius converging to a point. Moreover, force and moment equilibrium equations were used. In order to calculate factor of safety (FS) with the proposed method, a code was developed for two- and three-dimensional state. The model uses the iteration (trial and error) method to simultaneously satisfy force and moment equilibrium equations. In order to ensure convergence of the numerical model developed in the three dimensional state, the under relaxation method used in the trial and error operations. In examples, the proposed method was obtained the value of FS, 2.5 to 12 percent higher than other methods. In order to validate the proposed method and assess the functionality of the three dimensional numerical model a few examples were solved under different circumstances and the results were properly compliant with the results of other methods.


Main Subjects

1.Lin,  H.,  Xiong,  W.  and  Cao,  P.  Stability  of  soilnailed slope using strength reduction method",Euro-pean Journal of Environmental and Civil Engineering,17(9), pp. 872-885 (2013).2.Fellenius,  W.  Calculation  of  the  stability  of  earthdams", InTransactions of the 2nd Congress on LargeDams, Washington, DC,4, pp. 445-463 (1936).3.Bishop,   A.W.  The  use  of  the  slip  circle  in  thestability  analysis  of  slopes",Geotechnique,5(1),  pp.7-17 (1955).4.Lowe,  J.  and  Kara ath,  L.  Stability  of  earth  damsupon  drawdown",Proc.  1st.  Pan  American  Confer-ence  on  Soil  Mechanics  and  Foundation  Engineering,Mexico,2, pp. 537-552 (1960).5.Janbu,N.    Slope    stability    computations",InEmbankment-dam  Engineering, Hirshfeld and Poulos,Eds., John Wiley & Sons, New York (1973).6.U.S.  Army  Corps  of  Engineers,Stability   of   Earthand  Rock-Fill  Dams, U.S. Army Engineer WaterwaysExperiment Station, Vicksburg, MS. EM 1110-2-1902(1970).7.Spencer,  E.  A  method  of  analysis  of  the  stabilityof  embankments  assuming  parallel  inter-slice  forces",Geotechnique,17(1), pp. 11-26 (1967).8.Morgenstern, N.R. and Price, V.E. The analysis of thestability of general slip surfaces",Geotechnique,15(1),pp. 79-93 (1965).9.Sarma,  S.K.  Stability  analysis  of  embankments  andslopes",Geotechnique,23(3), pp. 423-433, (1973).10.Cheng, Y.M. Location of critical failure surface andsome further studies on slope stability analysis",Com-puters and Geotechnics,30(3), pp. 255-267 (2003).
M. Hajiazizi et al./Scientia Iranica, Transactions A: Civil Engineering 25 (2018) 129{13913911.Cheng,  Y.M.  and  Zhu,  L.J.  Uni ed  formulation  fortwo dimensional slope stability analysis and limitationsin factor of safety determination",Soils  and  Founda-tions,44(6), pp. 121-127 (2004).12.Zhu,  D.Y.,  Lee,  C.F.,  Qian,  Q.H.  and  Chen,  G.R.A  concise  algorithm  for  computing  the  factor  ofsafety  using  the  Morgenstern-Price  method",Cana-dian Geotechnical Journal,42(1), pp. 272-278 (2005).13.Hajiazizi, M. and Mazaheri, A.R. Use of line segmentsslip surface for optimized design of piles in stabilizationof  the  earth  slopes",International  Journal  of  CivilEngineering,13(1), pp. 14-27 (2015).14.Xiao, S., Yan, L. and Cheng, Z. A method combiningnumerical analysis and limit equilibrium theory to de-termine potential slip surfaces in soil slopes",Journalof Mountain Science,8(5), pp. 718-727 (2011).15.Liang,  D.D.L. Radiation slices method for arbitraryslip surface in analysis of slope stability",EngineeringGeology,6, p. 004 (2012).16.Hajiazizi,  M.  and  Tavana,  H.  Determining  three-dimensional non-spherical critical slip surface in earthslopes  using  an  optimization  method",EngineeringGeology,153, pp. 114-124 (2013).17.Cheng,  Y.M.,  Lansivaara,  T.  and  Siu,  J.  Impactof  convergence  on  slope  stability  analysis  and  de-sign",Computers and Geotechnics,35(1), pp. 105-113(2008).18.Hovland, H.J. Three-dimensional slope stability anal-ysis method",Journal of Geotechnical and EngineeringDivision, ASCE,103(9), pp. 971-986 (1977).19.Hungr,   O.   An   extension   of   Bishop's   Simpli edMethod  of  slope  stability  analysis  to  three  dimen-sions",Geotechnique,37(1), pp. 113-117 (1987).20.Ugai, K. and Hosobori, K. Stability analysis for slopeswith  arbitrary-shaped  geometry  and  sliding  forces",Journal of JSCE,412, pp. 183-186 (1989).21.Cheng,  Y.M. and Lau,  C.K. Slope stability analysisand  stabilization",New  Methods  and  Insight,  CRCPress (2008).22.Erzin,  Y. and Cetin,  T. The use of neural networksfor  the  prediction  of  the  critical  factor  of  safety  ofan  arti cial  slope  subjected  to  earthquake  forces",Scientia Iranica,19(2), pp. 188-194 (2012).23.Johari,  A.  and  Javadi,  A.A.  Reliability  assessmentof in nite slope stability using the jointly distributedrandom variables method",Scientia Iranica,19(3), pp.423-429 (2012).24.Johari,  A.,  Mousavi,  S.  and  Nejad,  A.H.  A  seismicslope  stability  probabilistic  model  based  on  Bishop'smethod  using  analytical  approach",Scientia  Iranica,22(3), pp. 728-741 (2015).25.Zhou,   X.P.  and  Cheng,   H.  Analysis  of  stabilityof  three-dimensional  slopes  using  the  rigorous  limitequilibrium  method",Engineering  Geology,160,  pp.21-33 (2013).26.Zhu,   D.Y.  and  Qian,   Q.H.  Rigorous  and  quasi-rigorous limit equilibrium solutions of 3D slope stabil-ity  and  application  to  engineering",Chinese  Journalof  Rock  Mechanics  and  Engineering,26(8), pp. 1513-1528 (2007).27.Cheng,   H.  and  Zhou,   X.  A  novel  displacement-based  rigorous  limit  equilibrium  method  for  three-dimensional  landslide  stability  analysis",CanadianGeotechnical Journal,52(12), pp. 2055-2066 (2015).28.Zhou,  X.P.  and  Cheng,  H.  The  long-term  stabilityanalysis of 3D creeping slopes using the displacement-based rigorous limit equilibrium method",EngineeringGeology,195, pp. 292-300 (2015).29.Wright,  S.G.  and  Duncan,  J.M.,Soil  Strength  andSlope Stability, John Wiley & Sons, Chapter 6 (2005).30.Wai-Fah,  C.,Limit  Analysis  and  Soil  Plasticity,  InElsevier  Scienti c  Publishing  Company,   New  York(1975).31.Nian,   T.K.,   Huang,   R.Q.,   Wan,   S.S.  and  Chen,G.Q. Three-dimensional strength-reduction  nite el-ement analysis of slopes:  geometric e ects",CanadianGeotechnical Journal,49(5), pp. 574-588 (2012).32.Wei,    W.B.,    Cheng,    Y.M.   and   Li,    L.   Three-dimensional  slope  failure  analysis  by  the  strengthreduction and limit equilibrium methods",Computersand Geotechnics,36(1), pp. 70-80 (2009).33.Ghahramani,   A.   The   stabilization   of   Saeen   andDashtegan  landslides",  InKey  Note  Lecture  at  theThird Congress of Civil Engineering, Tabriz University,Tabriz, Iran (2007).