Optimal control of hybrid electric vehicles by considering engine and tire/road noises

Document Type : Article


1 School of Mechanical Engineering, Sharif University of Technology, Tehran, P.O. Box 11155-9567, Iran

2 Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Postal Code T6G 2R3, Canada

3 School of System Design Engineering, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada


Along with exhaust emissions and fuel consumptions (FCs), noise emission from cars is one of the main concerns of the automotive industry. Hybridization is a promising method not only to make automobiles more environmentally-friendly, but also to reduce their noise emissions. However, a proper control design for hybrid electric vehicles (HEVs) to make noise emissions lower is still required in addition to exhaust emissions and FC reductions. In this study, we modify Equivalent Consumption Minimization Strategy (ECMS) to keep the engine noise less than tire/road noise during driving. A test bench is established for calculating the engine noise and brake specific fuel consumption. Moreover, the tire/road noise is experimentally defined as a function of the vehicle speed. It is shown that implementing the basic ECMS, the engine noise exceeds the tire/road noise in some moments of driving cycle, which is annoying to the passengers. Therefore, a modified ECMS is proposed to limit the candidate engine operating points such that the engine noise does not exceed the tire/road noise. It is shown that the engine noise level is kept below the tire/road noise level by using the modified ECMS at the expense of a very small increase in the vehicle’s FC.


[1]   Taghavipour, A., Vajedi, M. and Azad N. L. “Intelligent Control of Connected Plug-in Hybrid Electric Vehicles”, pp. 1-198, Springer International Publishing, Switzerland (2019).
[2]   Kumar, V., Rana, K. P. S., and  Mishra, P. “Robust speed control of hybrid electric vehicle using fractional order fuzzy PD and PI controllers in cascade control loop”, J Franklin Inst, 353(8), pp. 1713–1741 (2016).
[3]   Xu, D., Zhang, J., Zhou, B. et al. “Robust hierarchical estimator of clutch torques for a compound power-split hybrid electric vehicle”, MSSP, 134(1), pp. 1-17 (2019).
[4]   Ağbulut, Ü., Sarıdemir, S. and Karagöz, M. “Experimental investigation of fusel oil (isoamyl alcohol) and diesel blends in a CI engine”, Fuel, 267(1), pp. 1-8 (2020).
[5]   Huang, H. B., Huang, X. R., Yang, M. L. et al. “Identification of vehicle interior noise sources based on wavelet transform and partial coherence analysis”, MSSP, 109(1), pp. 247–267 (2018).
[6]   Qin, Y., Tang, Xi., Jia, T. et al. “Noise and vibration suppression in hybrid electric vehicles: State of the art and challenges”, Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev, 124(1), pp. 1-16 (2020).
[7]   Peng, J., He, H. and Xiong, R. “Rule based energy management strategy for a series–parallel plug-in hybrid electric bus optimized by dynamic programming”, Appl. Energy, 185(2), pp. 1633–1643 (2017).
[8]   Sabri, M., Danapalasingam, K. A. and Rahmat, M. F. “A review on hybrid electric vehicles architecture and energy management strategies”, Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev, 53(1), pp. 1433–1442 (2016).
[9]   Braun, M. E., Walsh, S. J., Horner, J. L. et al. “Noise source characteristics in the ISO 362 vehicle pass-by noise test: Literature review”, Appl. Acoust., 74(11), pp. 1241–1265 (2013).
[10] Guo, R., Cao, C., Mi, Y. et al. “Experimental investigation of the noise, vibration and harshness performances of a range-extended electric vehicle”, P I MECH ENG D-J AUT, 230(5), pp. 650–663 (2015).
[11] Sarıdemir, S. and Ağbulut, Ü. “Combustion, performance, vibration and noise characteristics of cottonseed methyl ester–diesel blends fuelled engine”, Biofuels, 1(10), pp. 1–10 (2019).
[12] Mosquera-Sánchez, J. A., Sarrazin, M., Janssens, K. et al. “Multiple target sound quality balance for hybrid electric powertrain noise”, MSSP, 99(1), pp. 478–503 (2018).
 [13]            Sandberg, U., Goubert, L. and Mioduszewski, P. “Are vehicles driven in electric mode so quiet that they need acoustic warning signals”, 20th Int. Cong. on Acoustics, Sydney, Australia, pp. 1-11 (2010).
[14] Dernotte, J., Dec, J. and Ji, C. “Investigation of the Sources of Combustion Noise in HCCI Engines”, SAE Int. J. Engines, 7(2), pp. 730–761 (2014).
[15] Bi, F., Li, L., Zhang, J. et al. “Source identification of gasoline engine noise based on continuous wavelet transform and EEMD–RobustICA” Appl. Acoust., 100(1), pp. 34–42 (2015).
[16] Donavan, P. and Rymer, B. “Assessment of Highway Pavements for Tire/Road Noise Generation”, SAE Technical Paper 2003-01-1536 (2003).
[17] Calvo, J. A., Álvarez-Caldas, C., San Román, J. L. et al. “Influence of vehicle driving parameters on the noise caused by passenger cars in urban traffic”, TRANSPORT RES D-TR E, 17(7), pp. 509–513 (2012).
 [18]            Jabben, J., Verheijen, E. and Potma, C. “Noise reduction by electric vehicles in the Netherlands”, Proc. of Internoise, New York, USA, pp. 1-8 (2012).
[19] Govindswamy, K., Wellmann, T. and Eisele, G. “Aspects of NVH integration in hybrid vehicles”, SAE Int. J. Passeng. Cars Mech. Syst., 2(1), pp. 1396–1405 (2009).
[20] Komada, M. and Yoshioka, T. “Noise and vibration reduction technology in new generation hybrid vehicle development”, SAE Technical Paper, 114(6), pp. 2648-2655 (2005).
[21] Guo, R., Mi, Y. and Cao, C. “Subjective and Objective Evaluation of APU Start-Stop NVH for a Range-Extended Electric Vehicle”, SAE Technical Paper 2015-01-0047 (2015).
[22] Pallas, M.A., Bérengier, M., Chatagnon, R. et al. “Towards a model for electric vehicle noise emission in the European prediction method CNOSSOS-EU”, Appl. Acoust., 113(1), pp. 89–101 (2016).
[23] Franck, D., van der Giet, M. and Hameyer, K. “Towards low audible noise drives for FEV applications”, 14th Int. EPE/PEMC, Aachen, Germany, pp. 25–30 (2010).
[24] GASPARONI, S., CZUKA, M., WEHR, R. et al. “Impact of low-noise tyres on electric vehicle noise emission”, IFSTTAR, Norway, pp.1-53 (2015).
[25] de Klerk, D. and Ossipov, A. “Operational transfer path analysis: Theory, guidelines and tire noise application”, MSSP, 24(7), pp. 1950–1962 (2010).
[26] Berckmans, D., Kindt, P., Sas, P. et al. “Evaluation of substitution monopole models for tire noise sound synthesis”, MSSP, 24(1), pp. 240–255 (2010).
[27] Hou, C., Xu, L., Wang, H. et al. “Energy management of plug-in hybrid electric vehicles with unknown trip length”, J Franklin Inst, 352(2), pp. 500–518 (2015).
[28] Montazeri-Gh, M., Poursamad, A. and Ghalichi, B. “Application of genetic algorithm for optimization of control strategy in parallel hybrid electric vehicles”, J Franklin Inst, 343(4), pp. 420–435 (2006).
[29] Delkhosh, M., Saadat Foumani, M. and Falahati, F. “A modified control strategy for parallel hybrid electric vehicles equipped with continuously variable transmission”, Sci. Iran., 23(3), pp. 966–975 (2016).
[30] Delkhosh, M., Saadat Foumani, M. and Rostami, P. “Optimization of powertrain and control strategy of hybrid electric vehicle,” Sci. Iran., 22(5), pp. 1842–1854 (2015).
[31] Solouk, A., Shakiba-herfeh, M., Kannan, K. et al. “Fuel Economy Benefits of Integrating a Multi-Mode Low Temperature Combustion (LTC) Engine in a Series Extended Range Electric Powertrain”, SAE Technical Paper 2016-10-17 (2016).
[32] Millo, F., Rolando, L., Mallamo, F. et al. “Development of an optimal strategy for the energy management of a range-extended electric vehicle with additional noise, vibration and harshness constraints”, P I MECH ENG D-J AUT, 227(1), pp. 4–16 (2013).
[33] Delkhosh, M., Aliramezani, M. and Khadem Nahvi, M. “Investigating the Effect of Engine Noise on Power Management Strategy of a Hybrid Electric Vehicle”, P I MECH ENG D-J AUT, 232(10), pp. 1287–1296 (2017).
[34] Delkhosh, M., Saadat Foumani, M., Azad, N. L. et al. “A new control strategy for hybrid electric vehicles equipped with continuously variable transmission”, P I MECH ENG D-J AUT, 230(6), pp. 803-816 (2015).
[35] Uludamar, E., Tosun, E. and Aydın, K. “Experimental and regression analysis of noise and vibration of a compression ignition engine fuelled with various biodiesels”, Fuel, 177(1), pp. 326–333 (2016).
[36] Shahlari, A. J., Hocking, C., Kurtz, E. et al. “Comparison of compression ignition engine noise metrics in low-temperature combustion regimes,” SAE Int. J. Engines, 6(1), pp. 541–552 (2013).
[37] Sandberg, U. “Tyre/road noise: myths and realities”, Int. Cong. Exhib. Noise Control Eng., Hauge, Netherland, pp.1-24 (2001).
[38] Sandberg, U. and Ejsmont, J. A. “Tyre/road Noise Reference Book”, pp.1-640, Informex Press, Kisa, Sweden (2002).
[39] Sciarretta, A., Back, M. and Guzzella, L. “Optimal Control of Parallel Hybrid Electric Vehicles”, IEEE T CONTR SYST T, 12(3), pp. 352–363 (2004).
[40] Park, J. and Park, J.H. “Development of equivalent fuel consumption minimization strategy for hybrid electric vehicles”, Int. J. Automot. Technol., 13(5), pp. 835–843 (2012).
[41] García, P., Torreglosa, J.P., Fernández, L. M. et al. “Viability study of a FC-battery-SC tramway controlled by equivalent consumption minimization strategy”, Int. J. Hydrog. Energy, 37(11), pp. 9368–9382 (2012).
[42] Zhang, C. and Vahid, A. “Real-time optimal control of plug-in hybrid vehicles with trip preview,” American Control Conference (ACC), pp. 6917–6922 (2010).
[43] “Saipa Corporation.” [Online]. Available: http://www.saipacorp.com/portal/Home/.
[44] “Gita Battery.” [Online]. Available: http://www.gitabattery.com/.
[45] “ADVISOR library reorganized structure.” http://adv-vehiclesim.sourceforge.net/LibReorg.html (2003).
[46] Delkhosh, M. and Saadat Foumani, M. “Multi-objective geometrical optimization of full toroidal CVT”, Int. J. Automot. Technol., 14(5), pp. 707–715 (2013).