Application of Taguchi method to determine the optimal water depth and glass cooling rate in solar stills

Document Type : Article


1 Department of Production Engineering and Mechanical Design, Faculty of Engineering, Tanta University, Tanta, Egypt

2 Department of Mechanical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Kafrelsheikh University, Kafrelsheikh, Egypt

3 Department of Mechanical Power Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Tanta University, Tanta, Egypt

4 - Department of Mechanical Power Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Tanta University, Tanta, Egypt. - Department of Automobile Engineering, Hindustan Institute of Technology and Science, Chennai-603103, Tamil Nadu, India.



The current study investigates the optimization of solar stills (SSs) productivity under different levels of solar radiation intensity, film cooling flow rate and water depth. Taguchi method is applied to perform a minimum number of experiments and to find the optimal water depth and cooling rate that maximize the productivity of the SS. An orthogonal array, signal-to-noise ratio and analysis of variance (ANOVA) are used to investigate the influence of the operating parameters on the solar still productivity. Taguchi method and ANOVA result several that water depth is the most influencing parameter. Furthermore, the results show that increasing the solar radiation and water film cooling improve the productivity. However, increasing the flow rate more than 4 kg/hr has a slight effect on the productivity. On the other hand, decreasing the water depth leads to a great enhancement in the productivity due to the faster evaporation and condensation rates. The levels of the operating parameters under-investigation are selected as follows: solar radiation intensity (5587,5673 and 5741 W/m2/day), film cooling flow rate (2, 4 and 6 kg/hr) and water depth (0.5, 1 and 1.5 cm). The improvement in the productivity with film cooling was about 6.05% at the water depth (0.5 cm)


[1] Sagade, A.A., Samdarshi, S.K., Lahkar, P.J. "Ensuring the completion of solar cooking process under unexpected reduction in solar irradiance", Solar Energy, 179,pp. 286-97  (2019(
[2] Rashit, O., Slushash, A., Dauren, O., Kunelbayev, M. "Integrated system for the use of solar energy in the animal farm", Scientia Iranica, 24,pp. 3213-22  (2017(
[3] Ghaebi, H., Bahadori, M.N., Saidi, M.H. "Economic and Environmental Evaluations of Different Operation Alternatives of an Aquifer Thermal Energy Storage in Tehran, Iran", Scientia Iranica, 24,pp. 610-23  (2017(
[4] Zayed, M.E., Zhao, J., Elsheikh, A.H., Hammad, F.A., Ma, L., Du, Y., et al. "Applications of cascaded phase change materials in solar water collector storage tanks: A review", Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells, 199,pp. 24-49  (2019(
[5] Zayed, M.E., Zhao, J., Elsheikh, A.H., Du, Y., Hammad, F.A., Ma, L., et al. "Performance augmentation of flat plate solar water collector using phase change materials and nanocomposite phase change materials: A review", Process Safety and Environmental Protection, 128,pp. 135-57  (2019(
[6] Zayed, M.E., Zhao, J., Elsheikh, A.H., Li, W., Elaziz, M.A. "Optimal design parameters and performance optimization of thermodynamically balanced dish/Stirling concentrated solar power system using multi-objective particle swarm optimization", Applied Thermal Engineering, 178,pp. 115539  (2020(
[7] Zayed, M.E., Zhao, J., Li, W., Elsheikh, A.H., Zhao, Z., Khalil, A., et al. "Performance prediction and techno-economic analysis of solar dish/stirling system for electricity generation", Applied Thermal Engineering, 164,pp. 114427  (2020(
[8] Rahbar, N., Esfahani, J.A., Asadi, A. "An experimental investigation on productivity and performance of a new improved design portable asymmetrical solar still utilizing thermoelectric modules", Energy Conversion and Management, 118,pp. 55-62  (2016(
[9] Sharshir, S.W., Elsheikh, A.H., Peng, G., Yang, N., El-Samadony, M.O.A., Kabeel, A.E. "Thermal performance and exergy analysis of solar stills – A review", Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 73,pp. 521-44  (2017(
[10] Sharshir, S.W., Peng, G., Elsheikh, A.H., Edreis, E.M.A., Eltawil, M.A., Abdelhamid, T., et al. "Energy and exergy analysis of solar stills with micro/nano particles: A comparative study", Energy Conversion and Management, 177,pp. 363-75  (2018(
[11] Kabeel, A., Bassuoni, M., Rozza, M. "Performance study of an innovative heating technique for a modified solar still", SCIENTIA IRANICA, 25,pp. 721-7  (2018(
[12] Sharshir, S.W., Ellakany, Y.M., Algazzar, A.M., Elsheikh, A.H., Elkadeem, M.R., Edreis, E.M.A., et al. "A mini review of techniques used to improve the tubular solar still performance for solar water desalination", Process Safety and Environmental Protection, 124,pp. 204-12  (2019(
[13] Elsheikh, A.H., Katekar, V.P., Muskens, O.L., Deshmukh, S.S., Elaziz, M.A., Dabour, S.M. "Utilization of LSTM neural network for water production forecasting of a stepped solar still with a corrugated absorber plate", Process Safety and Environmental Protection, 148,pp. 273-82  (2021(
[14] Sharshir, S.W., Peng, G., Wu, L., Yang, N., Essa, F.A., Elsheikh, A.H., et al. "Enhancing the solar still performance using nanofluids and glass cover cooling: Experimental study", Applied Thermal Engineering, 113,pp. 684-93  (2017(
[15] Elsheikh, A.H., Sharshir, S.W., Mostafa, M.E., Essa, F.A., Ahmed Ali, M.K. "Applications of nanofluids in solar energy: A review of recent advances", Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 82,pp. 3483-502  (2018(
[16] Sharshir, S.W., Peng, G., Wu, L., Essa, F.A., Kabeel, A.E., Yang, N. "The effects of flake graphite nanoparticles, phase change material, and film cooling on the solar still performance", Applied Energy, 191,pp. 358-66  (2017(
[17] Elsheikh, A.H., Sharshir, S.W., Ahmed Ali, M.K., Shaibo, J., Edreis, E.M.A., Abdelhamid, T., et al. "Thin film technology for solar steam generation: A new dawn", Solar Energy, 177,pp. 561-75  (2019(
[18] Essa, F.A., Elsheikh, A.H., Sathyamurthy, R., Muthu Manokar, A., Kandeal, A.W., Shanmugan, S., et al. "Extracting water content from the ambient air in a double-slope half-cylindrical basin solar still using silica gel under Egyptian conditions", Sustainable Energy Technologies and Assessments, 39,pp. 100712  (2020(
[19] Abu-Hijleh, B.A.K., Mousa, H.A. "Water film cooling over the glass cover of a solar still including evaporation effects", Energy, 22,pp. 43-8  (1997(
[20] Al-Garni, A.Z. "Productivity Enhancement of Solar Still Using Water Heater and Cooling Fan", Journal of Solar Energy Engineering, 134,pp. 031006-  (2012(
[21] Kabeel, A.E., Omara, Z.M., Essa, F.A. "Enhancement of modified solar still integrated with external condenser using nanofluids: An experimental approach", Energy Conversion and Management, 78,pp. 493-8  (2014(
[22] Iida, K., Yamamoto, T. " Residual stress induced by machining of steel", Shot Peener, 9,pp. 30-3  (1995(
[23] Essa, F.A., Elsheikh, A.H., Algazzar, A.A., Sathyamurthy, R., Ahmed Ali, M.K., Elaziz, M.A., et al. "Eco-friendly coffee-based colloid for performance augmentation of solar stills", Process Safety and Environmental Protection, 136,pp. 259-67  (2020(
[24] Kabeel, A.E., Sathyamurthy, R., Manokar, A.M., Sharshir, S.W., Essa, F.A., Elshiekh, A.H. "Experimental study on tubular solar still using Graphene Oxide Nano particles in Phase Change Material (NPCM's) for fresh water production", Journal of Energy Storage, 28,pp. 101204  (2020(
[25] Sharshir, S.W., Peng, G., Elsheikh, A.H., Eltawil, M.A., Elkadeem, M.R., Dai, H., et al. "Influence of basin metals and novel wick-metal chips pad on the thermal performance of solar desalination process", Journal of Cleaner Production, 248,pp. 119224  (2020(
[26] Sun, C., Liu, Y., Duan, C., Zheng, Y., Chang, H., Shu, S. "A mathematical model to investigate on the thermal performance of a flat plate solar air collector and its experimental verification", Energy Conversion and Management, 115,pp. 43-51  (2016(
[27] Gupta, B., Sharma, R., Shankar, P., Baredar, P. "Performance enhancement of modified solar still using water sprinkler: An experimental approach", Perspectives in Science, 8,pp. 191-4  (2016(
[28] El-Samadony, Y.A.F., Kabeel, A.E. "Theoretical estimation of the optimum glass cover water film cooling parameters combinations of a stepped solar still", Energy, 68,pp. 744-50  (2014(
[29] Tripathi, R., Tiwari, G.N. "Thermal modeling of passive and active solar stills for different depths of water by using the concept of solar fraction", Solar Energy, 80,pp. 956-67  (2006(
[30] Abu-Hijleh, B.A.K. "Enhanced solar still performance using water film cooling of the glass cover", Desalination, 107,pp. 235-44  (1996(
[31] Pawlak, A., Rosienkiewicz, M., Chlebus, E. "Design of experiments approach in AZ31 powder selective laser melting process optimization", Archives of Civil and Mechanical Engineering, 17,pp. 9-18  (2017(
[32] Elsheikh, A.H., Abd Elaziz, M. "Review on applications of particle swarm optimization in solar energy systems", International Journal of Environmental Science and Technology,pp.   (2018(
[33] Bao, Z., Yang, F., Wu, Z., Nyallang Nyamsi, S., Zhang, Z. "Optimal design of metal hydride reactors based on CFD–Taguchi combined method", Energy Conversion and Management, 65,pp. 322-30  (2013(
[34] Elsheikh, A.H., Sharshir, S.W., Abd Elaziz, M., Kabeel, A.E., Guilan, W., Haiou, Z. "Modeling of solar energy systems using artificial neural network: A comprehensive review", Solar Energy, 180,pp. 622-39  (2019(
[35] Asim, M., Zubair Khan, M., Alam Khan, L., Umer, M. "An integrated approach of quality for polymer composite manufacturing validated and optimized through Taguchi method", Scientia Iranica, 24,pp. 1985-95  (2017(
[36] Kolahan, F., Azadi Moghaddam, M. "The Use of Taguchi Method with Grey Relational Analysis to optimize the EDM Process Parameters with Multiple Quality Characteristics", Scientia Iranica, 22,pp. 530-8  (2015(
[37] Salman, K.h., Elsheikh, A.H., Ashham, M., Ali, M.K.A., Rashad, M., Haiou, Z. "Effect of cutting parameters on surface residual stresses in dry turning of AISI 1035 alloy", Journal of the Brazilian Society of Mechanical Sciences and Engineering, 41,pp. 349  (2019(
[38] Elsheikh, A.H., Deng, W., Showaib, E.A. "Improving laser cutting quality of polymethylmethacrylate sheet: experimental investigation and optimization", Journal of Materials Research and Technology, 9,pp. 1325-39  (2020(
[39] Youssef, Y.A., Beauchamp, Y., Thomas, M. "Comparison of a full factorial experiment to fractional and taguchi designs in a lathe dry turning operation", Computers & Industrial Engineering, 27,pp. 59-62  (1994(
[40] Tjantelé, M. "Parameter design using the Taguchi methodology", Microelectronic Engineering, 10,pp. 277-86  (1991(
[41] Chamoli, S. "A Taguchi approach for optimization of flow and geometrical parameters in a rectangular channel roughened with V down perforated baffles", Case Studies in Thermal Engineering, 5,pp. 59-69  (2015(
[42] Velmurugan, V., Deenadayalan, C.K., Vinod, H., Srithar, K. "Desalination of effluent using fin type solar still", Energy, 33,pp. 1719-27  (2008(
[43] Kabeel, A.E., Elkelawy, M., Alm El Din, H., Alghrubah, A. "Investigation of exergy and yield of a passive solar water desalination system with a parabolic concentrator incorporated with latent heat storage medium", Energy Conversion and Management, 145,pp. 10-9  (2017(
[44] Essa, F.A., Abd Elaziz, M., Elsheikh, A.H. "An enhanced productivity prediction model of active solar still using artificial neural network and Harris Hawks optimizer", Applied Thermal Engineering, 170,pp. 115020  (2020(
[45] Akhbari, A., Rahimi, M. "Performance and stability analysis of single-phase grid-connected inverters used in solar photovoltaic systems", scientiairanica, 26,pp. 1637-51  (2019).