Theoretical and experimental investigation of design parameter effects on the slip phenomenon and performance of a centrifugal compressor

Document Type : Article

Authors

School of Mechanical Engineering, Sharif University of Technology, Tehran, P.O. Box 11155/8639, Iran

Abstract

There are many pieces of research considering slip phenomenon in centrifugal compressors to drive equations for prediction of the slip factor. Inevitably, some simplifications have been imposed on the flow field characteristics and effects of many parameters have been neglected. In this research slip phenomenon is investigated experimentally and numerically in one centrifugal compressor with complex blade curves and splitter blades considering the main effective parameters. Three-dimensional simulation of the compressor viscus flow field with suitable turbulence method was performed using CFD methods. Experimental work was carried out at several rotational speeds and mass flow rates which enabled slip factor results of the compressor as well as, approving accuracy of the simulation results. Effect of main parameters such as rotational speed, mass flow rate, blade number, blade exit angle, diffuser design and tip clearance on slip phenomenon were studied. It was observed that slip factor increases, as rotational speed and flow rate increase. Also changing the blade number from 6 to 9 in constant rotational speed and mass flow rate, caused 27 percent increase in slip factor. For a detailed insight, a variation of performance parameters such as pressure ratio and isentropic efficiency with slip factor were investigated, as well.

Keywords


References
1. Caridad, A.J. and Kenyery, F. Slip factor for centrifugal
impellers under single and two-phase
ow
conditions", Journal of Fluids Engineering, 127, pp.
317{321 (2005).
2. Whit eld, A. and Baines, N., Design of Radial Turbomachines,
Harlow: Longman Scienti c and Technical,
pp. 83{134 (1990).
3. Ball, A.G., Bell, A.H., and Mann, L.B. The development
of the Chrysler automotive centrifugal compressor",
In SAE International Congress And Exposition
of Automotive Engineering (1961).
S. Rajabpour et al./Scientia Iranica, Transactions B: Mechanical Engineering 28 (2021) 291{304 303
4. Wiesner, F.J. A review of slip factors for centrifugal
impellers", Journal of Engineering for Power, 89(4),
pp. 558{566 (1967).
5. Aungier, R.H., Centrifugal Compressor: A Strategy for
Aerodynamics Design and Analysis, New York, ASME
Press (2000).
6. Stodola, A., Steam and Gas Turbines, New York,
McGraw-Hill (1927).
7. Wislicenus, F.G., Fluid Mechanics of Turbomachinery,
New York, McGraw-Hill (1947).
8. Sheets, H.E. The
ow through centrifugal compressors
and pumps", In Trans. Amer. Soc. Mech. Engrs,
72, p. 1009 (1950).
9. Stanitz, D.J. Some theoretical aerodynamic investigations
of impellers in radial and mixed-
ow centrifugal
compressors", In ASME, Cleveland, Ohio (1952).
10. Zhang, Y.L., Zhu, Z.C., Dou, H.S., Cui, B.L., Li,
Y., and Xiao, J.J. A method to determine the
slip factor of centrifugal pumps through experiment",
International Journal of Turbo & Jet-Engines, 32(1),
pp. 59{64 (2015).
11. Whit eld, A. Slip factor of a centrifugal compressor
and its variation with
ow rate", Proceedings of the
Institution of Mechanical Engineers, 188, pp. 415{421
(1974).
12. Von Backstrom, T. A compact equation for the prediction
of eddy-induced slip in centrifugal impellers",
IMechE Part A: J. Power and Energy, 220(8), pp.
911{915 (2006).
13. Von Backstrom, T. A uni ed correlation for slip factor
in centrifugal impellers", Journal of Turbomachinery,
128(1), pp. 1{10 (2006).
14. Ji, C., Zou, J., and Fu, X. A new correlation for slip
factor in radial and mixed-
ow impellers", Journal of
Power and Energy, 225(1), pp. 114{119 (2010).
15. Elsheshtawy, A. Numerical study of slip factor in
centrifugal pumps and study factors a ecting its performance",
In International Conference on Mechanical
Engineering and Material Science (2012).
16. Hung, J. and Lou, K. Numerical investigations of slip
phenomena in centrifugal compressor impellers", Turbo
Jet-Engines, 30(1), pp. 123{132 (2013).
17. Xuwen, Q., Japikse, D., and Zhai, J. Analysis and
validation of a uni ed slip factor model for impellers
at design and o -design conditions", J. Turbomach.,
133(4), 041018 (Oct. 2011).
https://doi.org/10.1115/1.4003022
18. Ntoko, N. A dynamical basis for slip in centrifugal
impellers", IMechE: Power and Energy, 226(5), pp.
706{711 (2012).
19. Ghaderi, M., Naja , A., and Nourbakhsh, A. Improving
slip factor prediction for centrifugal pumps using
arti cial neural networks", IMechE Part A: Power and
Energy, 229(4), pp. 431{438 (2015).
https://doi.org/10.1177/0957650915580884
20. Plfeiderer, C.F., Die Kreiselpumpen fur Flussigkeiten
und Gase, Berlin: Springer (1961).
21. Dean, C.R. On the unresolved
uid dynamics of the
centrifugal compressor", Adv Centrifugal Compressors,
ASME Special Publication, pp. 1{55 (1971).
22. Van den Braembussche, R., Design and Analysis of
Centrifugal Compressors, von Karman Institute, Belgium:
ASME Press and John Wiley & Sons Ltd (2019).
23. Hajilouy Benisi, A., Rad, M., and Shahhosseini, M.R.
Flow and performance characteristic of twin-entry
radial turbine under full and extreme partial admission
conditions", Scientia Iranica: Mechanical Engineering,
79, pp. 1127{1143 (2003).
24. Doost Mohamadi, A., Hajilouy Benisi, A., and Mojaddam,
M. Experimental & numerical investigation
of losses in centrifugal compressor components", In
ASME: Turbine Technical Conference and Exposition,
San Antonio, Texas (2013).
25. Mojaddam, M. and Hajilouy-Benisi, A. Experimental
and numerical
ow eld investigation through two
types of radial
ow compressor volutes", Experimental
Thermal and Fluid Science, 78, pp. 137{146 (2016).
26. Performance test code for compressors and exhausters,
ASME (1997).
27. Test uncertainty, ASME (2013).
28. Pressure measurement: Instruments and apparatus
supplement, ASME (2010).
29. PTC 19.3 TW thermowells, ASME (2016).
30. Brun, K. and Kurz, R. Measurement uncertainties
encountered during gas turbine driven compressor eld
testing", Journal of Engineering for Gas Turbines and
Power, 123, pp. 62{69 (2001).
31. Nakra, B.C. and Chaudhry, K.K., Instrumentation,
Measurement And Analysis, New Delhi, McGraw-Hill
(2003).
32. Mojaddam, M., Hajilouy Benisi, A., and Movahhedy,
M. Optimal design of the volute for a turbocharger
radial
ow compressor", In ASME: Turbine Technical
Conference and Exposition, Dusseldorf (2014).
33. Versteeg, H. and Malalasekera, W., An Introduction to
Computational Fluid Dynamics: The Finite Volume
Method, 2nd Edition, Harlow, Longman Scienti c &
Technical (2007).
34. Rodrigues, T.T. Tubulence modelling evaluation for
reciprocating compressor simulation", In International
Compressor Engineering Conference, Purdue University
(2014).
35. Moussavi, S.A., Hajilouy Benisi, A., and Durali, M.
E ect of splitter leading edge location on performance
of an automotive turbocharger compressor", Energy,
123, pp. 511{520 (2017).
36. Kim, C., Lee, H., Yang, J., Son, C., and Hwang, Y.
Study on the performance of a centrifugal compressor
considering running tip clearance", International
Journal of Refrigeration, 65, pp. 92{102 (2016).
304 S. Rajabpour et al./Scientia Iranica, Transactions B: Mechanical Engineering 28 (2021) 291{304
37. Galindo, J., Tiseira, A., Navarro, R., and Lopez, M.A.
In
uence of tip clearance on
ow behavior and noise
generation of centrifugal compressors in near-surge
conditions", International Journal of Heat and Fluid
Flow, 52, pp. 129{139 (2015).
38. Zhang, C., Jun, H., and Zhiqiang, W. Threedimensional
compressor blading design improvements
in low-speed model testing", Aerospace Science and
Technology, 63, pp. 179{190 (2016).
39. Asgarshamsi A., Hajilouy Benisi A., Assempour A.,
and Pourfarzaneh, H. Multi-objective optimization of
lean and sweep angles for stator and rotor blades of
an axial turbine", Proc IMechE Part G: J. Aerospace
Engineering, 229(5), pp. 906{916 (2015).