Experimental study of the wedge effects on the performance of a hard-chine planing craft in calm water

Document Type : Article

Authors

Department of Marine Technology, Amirkabir University of Technology, Hafez Ave, No 424, Tehran, P.O. Box 15875-4413, Iran.

Abstract

In this paper, effects of a wedge on the performance of planing craft in calm water are experimentally investigated. Experiments are carried out on three different cases distinguished by the wedge type. The model, built of fiberglass, is a prismatic planing hull with deadrise angle of 24 degrees. Towing tests are conducted at different Froude numbers ranging from 0.21 to 2.1. The total trim angle, resistance, rise up at the CG as well as stern and bow, keel wetted length, chine wetted length, stagnation angle, and the length of stagnation line are measured. They are used to study the effect of installing a wedge on the performance as well as the effect of height on the hydrodynamic characteristics. Based on the observations made, it is concluded that, when the wedge is applied to the hull, the risk of model exhibiting instability diminishes, while total trim angle largely decreases, keel wetted length is enlarged, wetted surface becomes thinner, CG rise up is lowered, and the resistance is reduced. Moreover, experimental measurements and theoretical 2D+T theory are combined to bring deeper insight about physics of the flow and pressure distribution when a wedge is installed on the bottom of a planing hull. 

Keywords

Main Subjects


1. Blount, D.L. and Codega, L.T. Dynamic stability of planing boats", Int. J. of Marine Technology, 29(1), pp. 4-12 (1992). 2. Katayama, T., Taniguchi, T., and Habara, K. Tank tests to estimate onset of dynamic instabilities of highspeed planing craft", 2th Int. Conf. Chesapeake Power Boat, Annapolis, MD, USA (2010). 3. De la Cruz, J.M., Aranda, J.M., Girson sierra, F., et al. Improving the comfort of a fast ferry", IEEE Control System Magazine, 24(2), pp. 47-60 (2004). 4. Xi, H. and Sun, J. Vertical plane motion of high speed planing vessels with controllable transom aps: modeling and control", 16th Int. Triennial World Congress of International Federation of Automatic Control, Prague, Czech Republic (2005). 5. van Deyzen, A. Improving the operability of planing monohulls using proactive control", PhD Thesis, Delft TU, Delft, Netherlands (2014). 6. Savitsky, D. and Brown, P.W. Procedures for hydrodynamic evaluation of planning hulls in smooth and rough water", Int. J. of Marine Technology, 13(4), pp. 381-400 (1976). 7. Millward, A. E_ect of wedges on the performance characteristics of two planing hulls", Int. J. of Ship Research, 20(4), pp. 224-232 (1987). 8. Kara_ath, G. and Fisher, S. The e_ect of stern wedges on ship powering performance", Int. J. of Naval Engineers, 99(3), pp. 27-38 (1987). 9. Wang, C.T. Wedge e_ect on planing hulls", Int. J. of Hydronautics, 14(4), pp. 122-124 (1980). 10. Tsai, F. and Hwang, J.L. Study on the compound e_ects of interceptor with stern ap for two fast monohulls", Conference: Oceans '04 MTS/IEEE Techno- Ocean '04 (2004). 11. Cumming, D., Pallard, R., Thornhill, E., Hally, D., and Dervin, M., Hydrodynamic Design of a Stern Flap Appendage for the HALIFAX Class Frigates, Mari- Tech, Halifax, N.S (June 14-16, 2006). 12. Jang, S.H., Lee, H.J., Joo, Y.R., Kim, J.J., and Chun, H.H. Some practical design aspects of appendages for passenger vessels", Int. J. of Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering, 1, pp. 50-56 (2009). 13. Steen, S., Alterskjar, S.A., Velgaard, A., and Aasheim, I. Performance of a planing craft with mid-mounted interceptor", 10th Int. Conf. on Fast Sea Transportation, Athens, Greece (2009). 14. Karimi, M.H., Seif, M.S., and Abbaspoor, M. An experimental study of interceptor's e_ectiveness on hydrodynamic performance of high-speed planing crafts", Polish Maritime Research, 20, pp. 21-29 (2013). 15. Savitsky, D. Hydrodynamic design of planing hulls", Int. J. of Marine Technology, 1(1), pp. 71-95 (1964). 16. Ikeda, Y., Yokmi, K., Hamaski, J., Umeda, N. and Katayama, T. Simulation of running attitudes and resistance of a high-speed craft using a database of hydrodynamic forces obtained by fully captive model experiments", 2th Int. Conf. on Fast Sea Transportation, Athens, Greece (1993). 17. Ghadimi, P., Tavakoli, S., Feizi Chakab, M.A., and Dashtimanesh, A. Introducing a particular mathematical model for predicting the resistance and performance of prismatic planing hulls in calm water by means of total pressure distribution", Int. J. of Naval Architecture and Marine Engineering, 12(2), pp. 73-94 (2015). 18. Martin, M. Theoretical determination of porpoising instability of high-speed planing boat", Report No. 76- 0068 David Taylor Naval Ship Research and Development Center (1976). 19. Xu, L. and Troesch, A.W. A study on hydrodynamic of asymmetric planing surfaces", 5th Int. Conf. on Fast Sea Transportation, Seattle, Washington, USA (1999). 20. Ghadimi, P., Tavakoli, S., Dashtimanesh, A., and Zamanian, R. Steady performance prediction of a heeled planing boat in calm water using asymmetric 2D+T model", Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part M: Journal of Engineering for the Maritime Environment, 231(1), pp. 234-257 (2016a). 21. Ghadimi, P., Loni, A., Nowruzi, H., Dashtimanesh, A., and Tavakoli, S. Parametric study of the e_ects of trim tabs on running trim and resistance of planing hulls", Int. J. of Advances in Shipping and Ocean Engineering, 3(1), pp. 1-12 (2014). 22. Taunton, D.J., Hudson, D.A., and Shenoi, R.A. Characteristics of a series of high speed hard chine planing hills- Part 1: Performance in calm water", Int. J. of Small Craft Technology, 152(2), pp. B55-B74 (2010). 23. Begovic, E. and Bertorello, C. Resistance assessment of warped hull form", Int. J. of Ocean Engineering, 56, pp. 28-42 (2012). 24. Ma, W.J., Sun, H.B., Zou, J., and Zhaung, J.Y. Test studies of the resistance and seakeeping performance of trimaran planing hull", Polish Maritime Research, 22, pp. 22-27 (2015). 25. Jiang, Y., Zou, J., Hu, A., and Yang, J. Analysis of tunnel hydrodynamic characteristics for planing trimaran by model test and numerical simulations", Int. J. of Ocean Engineering, 113, pp. 101-110 (2016). 26. Kim, D.J., Kim, S.Y., You, Y.J., et al. Design of highspeed planing hulls for the improvement of resistance and seakeeping performance", Int. J. of Naval Archit Ocean Eng., 5, pp. 161-177 (2013). 27. Seo, J., Chori, H.K., Jeong, U.C., et al. Model tests on resistance and seakeeping performance of wavepiercing high-speed vessel with spray rails", Int. J. of Naval Archit Ocean Eng., 8(5), pp. 442-455 (2017). 28. Taunton, D.J., Hudson, D.A., and Shenoi, R.A. Characteristics of a series of high speed hard chine planing hills- Part 2: Performance in waves", Int. J. of Small Craft Technology, 153(1), pp. B1-B22 (2011). 29. Begovic, E., Bertorello, C., and Pennino, S. Experimental seakeeping assessment of a warped planing hull model series", Int. J. of Ocean Engineering, 83, pp. 1-15 (2014). 30. Judge, C.Q. and Judge, J.A. Measurement of hydrodynamic coe_cients on a planing Hull using forced roll oscillations", Int. J. of Ship Research, 57, pp. 112-124 (2013). 31. Morabito, M.G. Prediction of planing hull side forces in yaw using slender body oblique impact theory", Int. J. of Ocean Engineering, 101, pp. 47-57 (2015). 32. Morabito, M., Pavkov, M., Timmins, C., and Beaver, B. Experiments on directional stability of stepped planing hulls", Proceedings of the 4th Chesapeake Power Boat Symposium, Annapolis, MD, US (2014). 33. Katayama, T. Mechanism of porpoising instabilities for high-speed planing craft", Proceedings of the Sixth ISOPE Paci_c/Asia O_shore Mechanics Symposium (2004). 34. ITTC Recommended Procedures and Guidelines, 24th ITTC 7.5-02 07-02.1 (2005). 35. Lee, E.J., Schleicher, C.C., Merrill, C.F., Fullerton, D.A., et al. Benchmark testing of generic prismatic planing hull (GPPH) for validation of CFD tools", In proceedings of the 30th American Towing Tank Conference (ATTC), Bethesda, Maryland (2017). 36. Lee, E., Fullerton, A., Geiser, L., Schleicher, C., et al. Experimental and computational comparisons of the R=V Athena in calm water", In Proceedings of the 31st Symposium on Naval Hydrodynamics, Monterey, CA, USA (2016). 37. Celano, T. The prediction of porpoising inception for modern planing craft", SNAME Transaction, 106, pp. 296-292 (1998). 38. Katayama, T., Fujimoto, M., and Ikeda, Y. A study in transverse stability loss of planing craft at super high forward speed", In 9th Int. Conf. on Stability of Ships and Ocean Vehicles, Rio de Janerio, Brazil (2006). 39. Savitsky, D., DeLorme, M.F., and Datla, R. Inclusion of whisker spray drag in performance prediction method for high-speed planing hulls", Int. J. of Marine Technology, 44(1), pp. 35-56 (2007). 40. Ghadimi, P., Tavakoli, S., Dashtimanesh, A., and Pirooz, A. Developing a computer program for detailed study of planing hull's spray based on Morabito's approach", Int. J. of Marine Science and Application, 13(4), pp. 402-415 (2014). 41. Akers, R.H. Dynamic analysis of planing hulls in vertical plane", In Proceedings of the Society of Naval Architects and Marine Engineers, New England Section (1999). 42. Ghadimi, P., Tavakoli, S., and Dashtimanesh, A. Calm water performance of hard-chine vessels in semiplaning and planing regimes", Polish Maritime Res., 23(4), pp. 23-45 (2016). 43. Van Deyzen, A. A nonlinear mathematical model for motions of a planing monohull in head seas", 6th Int. Conf. on High Performance Marine Vehicles, Naples, Italy (2008). 44. Zarnick, E.E. A nonlinear mathematical model of motions of a planing boat in regular waves", Report No. 78/032, David Taylor Naval Ship Research and Development Center (1978). 45. Garme, K. and Rosen, A. Time domain simulations and full-scale trials on planing crafts in waves", Int. J. of Ship Building Progress, 50(3), pp. 177-208 (2003). 46. Ghadimi, P., Tavakoli, S., and Dashtimanesh, A. Coupled heave and pitch motions of planing hulls at non-zero heel angle", Int. J. of Applied Ocean Research, 59, pp. 286-303 (2016). 47. Haase, H., Sopron, J.P., and Abdel-Maksoud, M. Numerical analysis of a planing boat in head waves using a 2D+T method", Int. J. of Ship Technology Research, 62(3), pp. 131-139 (2015). 48. Sebastiani, L., Bruzzone, D., Gualeni, P., et al. A practical method for the prediction of planing craft motions in regular and irregular waves", 27th Int. Conf. on O_shore Mechanics and Arctic Engineering, Estoril, Portugal (2008). 49. Tavakoli, S., Ghadimi, P., Dashtimanesh, A., and Sahoo, P.K. Determination of hydrodynamic coe_cients related to roll motion of high-speed planing hulls", 13th Int. Conf. on Fast Sea Transportation, DC, USA (2015). 50. Ghadimi, P., Tavakoli, S., and Dashtimanesh, A. An analytical procedure for time domain simulation of roll motion of the warped planing hulls", Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part M: Int. J. of Engineering for the Maritime Environment, 230, pp. 600-615 (2016). 51. Tavakoli, S., Ghadimi, P., and Dashtimanesh, A. A nonlinear mathematical model for coupled heave, pitch, and roll motions of a high-speed planing hull", Int. J. of Engineering Mathematics, 104, pp. 157-194 (2017). 52. Ghadimi, P., Tavakoli, S., Dashtimanesh, A., and Taghikhani, P. Dynamic response of a wedge through asymmetric free fall in 2 degrees of freedom", Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers Part M: Int. J. of Engineering for the Maritime Environment, Published Online, 233(1), pp. 229-250 (2017). 53. Farsi, M. and Ghadimi, P. Finding the best combination of numerical schemes for 2D SPH simulation of wedge water entry for a wide range of deadrise angles", Int. J. of Naval Archit Ocean Eng., 6, pp. 638-651 (2014). 54. Farsi, M. and Ghadimi, P. E_ect of at deck on catamaran water entry through smoothed particle hydrodynamics", Institution of Mechanical Engineering, Part M: Int. J. of Engineering for the Maritime Environment, Published Online, Marc, 230(2), pp. 267-280 (2014). 55. Facci, A.L., Panciroli, R., Ubertini, S., and Por_ri, M. Assessment of PIV-based analysis of water entry problems through synthetic numerical datasets", Int. J. of Fluids and Structures, 55, pp. 484-500 (2015). 56. Ghadimi, P., Feizi Chekab, M.A., and Dashtimanesh, A. A numerical investigation of the water impact of an arbitrary bow section", ISH Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 19(3), 186-195 (2013). 57. Shademani, R. and Ghadimi, P. Parametric investigation of the e_ects of deadrise angle and demi-hull separation on impact forces and spray characteristics of catamaran water entry", Int. J. of the Brazilian Society of Mechanical Sciences and Engineering, 39(6), pp. 1989-1999 (2017). 58. Shademani, R. and Ghadimi, P. Numerical assessment of turbulence e_ects on forces, spray parameters, and secondary impact in wedge water entry problem using k-epsilon method", Int. J. of Scientia Iranica, published online, 24(1), pp. 223-236 (2017). 59. Shademani, R. and Ghadimi, P. Asymmetric water entry of twin wedges with di_erent deadrises, heel angles, and wedge separations using _nite element based _nite volume method and VOF", Int. J. of Applied Fluid Mechanics, 10(1), pp. 353-368 (2017). 60. Feizi Chekab, M.A., Ghadimi, P., and Farsi, M. Investigation of three-dimensionality e_ects of aspect ratio on water impact of 3D objects using smoothed particle hydrodynamics method", Int. J. of the Brazilian Society of Mechanical Sciences and Engineering, 38(7), pp. 1987-1998 (2016). 61. Shademani, R. and Ghadimi, P. Estimation of water entry forces, spray parameters and secondary impact of _xed width wedges at extreme angles using _- nite element based _nite volume and volume of uid methods", Int. J. of Brodogradnja, 67(1), pp. 101-124 (2017). 62. Farsi, M. and Ghadimi, P. Simulation of 2D symmetry and asymmetry wedge water entry by smoothed particle hydrodynamics method", Int. J. of the Brazilian Society of Mechanical Sciences and Engineering, 37(3), pp. 821-835 (2017). 63. Ghadimi, P., Dashtimanesh, A., and Djeddi, S.R. Study of water entry of circular cylinder by using analytical and numerical solutions", Int. J. of the Brazilian Society of Mechanical Sciences and Engineering, 34(3), pp. 225-232 (2015). 64. Korobkin, A.A. Second-order Wagner theory of wave impact", Int. J. of Engineering Mathematics, 58(1-4), pp. 121-139 (2007). 65. Ghadimi, P., Saadatkhah, A., and Dashtimanesh, A. Analytical solution of wedge water entry by using schwartz-christo_el conformal mapping", Int. J. of Modeling, Simulation and Scienti_c Computing, 2(3), pp. 337-354 (2013). 66. Judge, C., Troesch, A.W., and Prelin, M. Initial water impact of a wedge at vertical and oblique angles", Int. J. of Eng. Math, 48, pp. 279-303 (2004). 67. Ghadimi, P., Feizi Chekab, M.A., and Dashtimanesh, A. Numerical simulation of water entry of di_erent arbitrary bow sections", Int. J. of Naval Arch. Marine Eng., 11, pp. 117-129 (2014). 68. Panciroli, R. and Por_ri, M. Evaluation of the pressure _eld on a rigid body entering a quiescent uid through particle image velocimetry", Exp. Fluids, 54, pp. 1630-1642 (2013). 69. Jalalisendi, M., Osma, S.J., and Por_ri, M. Threedimensional water entry of a solid body: a particle image velocimetry study", Int. J. of Fluids and Structures, 59, pp. 85-102 (2015). 70. Jalalisendi, M., Shams, A., Panciroli, R., and Por_ri, M. Experimental reconstruction of threedimensional hydrodynamic loading in water entry problems through particle image velocimetry", Exp. Fluids, 56, pp. 1-17 (2015). 71. Shams, A., Jalalisendi, M., and Por_ri, M. Experiments on the water entry of asymmetric wedges using particle image velocimetry", Physics of Fluids, 27(2) (2015). DOI: 10.1063/1.4907745 72. Facci, A.L., Panciroli, R., Ubertini, S., and Por_ri, M. Assessment of PIV-based analysis of water entry problems through synthetic numerical datasets", Int. J. of Fluids and Structures, 55, pp. 484-500 (2015). 73. Facci, A.L., Por_ri, M., and Ubertini, S. Threedimensional water entry of a solid body: A computational study", Int. J. of Fluids and Structures, 66, pp. 36-53 (2016). 74. Tveitnes, T., Flailie-Clarke, A.C., and Varyani, K. An experimental investigation into the constant velocity water entry of wedge-shaped sections", Int. J. of Ocean Engineering, 35, pp. 1463-1478 (2016). 75. Wagner, H. The landing of seaplanes. Technical Rep", Technical Note 622, 254, NACA (1932). 76. Garme, K. Improved time domain simulation of planing hulls in waves by correction of near-transom lift", International Journal of Shipbuilding Progress, 52(3), pp. 201-230 (2005). 77. Breslin, J.P. Chines-dry planing of slender hulls: A general theory applied to prismatic surfaces", Int. J. of Ship Research, 45(1), pp. 59-72 (2001). 78. Ghadimi, P., Tavakoli, S., Dashtimanesh, A., and Zamanian, P. Steady performance prediction of a heeled planing boat in calm water using asymmetric 2D+T model", Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part M: Journal of Engineering for the Maritime Environment, 231, pp. 234-257 (2017).